If Bellew beats Usyk, is he in the Top 5 P4P?

No. None of the fighters you mention are good enough to put him there, Haye was done, the rest are average. But if he beats Usyk i'll stop watching Boxing as it'll prove I know f all

 

Yes Top 6 & if he does make it to the Top 6 we know Sylvester got him Top 6 with some secret "moon blood"

 

Surely this is a step too far for Bellew.

 

Not sure about top 5 but you could reasonably put him in top 10. Would be one of the strangest things I've witnessed though to have Bellew in a p4p list.

 

No. I keep forgetting he beat Chilemba. I never saw that fight.

 

Yes he is!!! As he would have beat a top 5 elite fighter.

 

he's not going to win. usyk is going to beat him with ease.

 

If Bellew beats Usyk it will put many on suicide watch, myself included.

 

Depends on how. If he just catches him and knocks him out, then now, but if outboxes or knock him out in very close fight, then yeah. At least in the top 10

 

Who cares!

 

No, because the only way he's beating Usyk, in my estimation, is with a lucky punch. Meanwhile, in the context of being considered for inclusion in any top #5 P4P list, neither does stopping a visibly shot David Haye count for much in my mind. However, if (assuming he stops Usyk) he then, instead of retiring, goes on to beat two or three more elite/future HOF opponents at CW or HW, then this would certain help convince me that, instead of getting lucky, Tony is able to employ some technical skill and ring IQ to set up his knock out punches. Then (and only then) would I feel comfortable with him being included in any top #5 P4P list.

 

The chance is so remote we'll probably not have to think about it, but will cross that bridge if we come to it. Bellew has a big punch so there's always that, but aside from the massive skill he has - Usyk also has a really solid chin and heaps of heart so a lucky shot probably won't be enough.

 

I might actually stop following the sport.