If both Manny and Floyd retired today....

Floyd's glass jaw is his downfall....as well as not being fit to lace the ATG's laces.

 

They are not the same weight. But judging by the quality of opposition and the span of weight they fought, I would say, Pac rates higher.

 

At any weight he would not be competitive at smaller weights maybe buy with the big bangers no.

 

Pacquiao.

END THREAD

 

If you like Pacquiao then Pacquiao is higher, if you like both then Floyd is higher.

 

Manny Pacquaio's legacy rates far higher than Floyd Mayweather jr's
Don't forget Manny was voted fighter of the decade and Floyd "RETIRED" to avoid having to take dangerous fights
All this fight will prove is, that's if its a fair & above board contest, who is the best man on May 2 not who is P4P atg best.
Manny's legacy has already outshone Floyd's he ranks higher Win or lose Manny >>>>>>>>>> Floyd

 

Money and it ain't even close. Anyone who says or thinks otherwise DKSAB.

 

There fixed it for ya

 

Pac by a significant margin

 

Mayweather ranks higher. He is better period.

 

This is as easy as it gets. PacMan hands down.

When it mattered most, Fraud Runawayther either retired or ducked. It's that simple. He has no one to blame but himself. End of story.

 

Floyd has to be higher. You can't be the consensus #1 fighter of your generation and be ranked behind anyone in your generation. Anyway you look at it, Floyd has to rank above him. Even more so if he wins this fight,

 

I have the opposite, no such atg gets destroyed all throughout their primes

 

This fight will decide it

 

Ali fought Liston twice Frazier three times Norton three times and Foreman . That is three quarters of Floyds fights in the last tens years .
Ray Leonard Fought Hagler Hearns Duran Benitez Ayub Kalule.
Oscar Dela Hoya Fought Felix Trinidad Shane Mosely Ike Quartey Bernard Hopkins .
These fights were when both fighters were near there peaks .

How hard is it to understand why Floyd does not rate anywhere near the top?