If Calzaghe beats Kessler TOP3 PVP NO QUESTION ?

I guess 10 years of dominance don't count. beating multiple top tens dont count. Beating the concensus number one at smw doesn't count.

 

Then! Not now! He's too old unless his last fight was an anomanaly.

 

So if he beats Calzaghe, he ISN'T overrated? But right now, he is? But Calzaghe is a bum and fraud to you? Contradictory....

 

Don't even try to reason with this guy. I think he's here as some kind of social experiment.

 

To Richie Woodhall in Setanta Sports Boxing Chat and available on you tube, Calzaghe is already the best fighter in the world pound per pound and faced with the similarities in age and against whom he is put against with Shane Mosley, Richie says that Joe should have 3 great last fights in him and Shane not even one... And that gat to be biased! If Joe Calzhage beats Mikkel Kessler, he becomes the undefeated long time WBO Super Middleweight Champion of the World and the WBC and WBA "Super" versions titlist and that puts him in the Top 3 in the World right behind Floyd and Manny but only if...

 

Because we both know that being overrated and underrated has alot more to do with the overall general point of view than a fighter and not his direct relation to one particular fighter. You know this, and this wasn't even a good attempt at hiding it.

You also set up a position where you can always claim that BOTH fighters are bums no matter what.

 

Wow! Thats just....wow!:admin
Now I do think that Amsterdam (lets not even get started on CHJ ) gets a bit carried away with Joe, but to say he's not elite smacks of some kind of bias.
And to say Kessler is not a world beater leads me too believe that I'm wasting my time here. I mean thats a bizzare statement to make. The potential is there for all to see and his fight against Joe is his first major step up.

 

Thanks for being realistic about all this. There's no getting through to some of Calzaghe's fans.

 

Hatton fans are even worse, you all think he's got even a slight shot at Floyd, when he's realistically just taking a big payday.

 

If he destroys Kessler he will probally be #2 on my list, if he wins a fairly wide UD he will be #3, and if he wins a razor thin decision that can go either way he will be about #5.

 

I'm not a Hatton fan you muppet. If Hatton doesn't have even a slight shot at Floyd 4/9 are increadible odds. Why don't you put a few grand down?

If Calzaghe had set up a fight with Roy Jones in 2002, he'd be given very little chance of winning too but he should have tried. Hatton got rid of his WBU title, went to the States to fight and also won a title in a higher division. Now he gets a shot at the P4P number 1. Maybe you're jealous? If you're not Calzaghe himself I don't see why you should be but you do seem quite emotionally involved.

 

I'll move him close to my top 5, if he dominates Mikkel then perhaps a top 5 spot is warranted, otherwise he'll be 6 or 7 (have him at #9 currently).

As has been mentioned Kessler himself is not a P4P fighter at this point, though he is the clear #2 at the weight.

 

What if Kessler wins?