if David Haye beats Maccarinelli would he be a P4P 10

Yes as he would be clearly the best cruiserweight fighter beating two of the best 5 cruiserweights within 6 months.

 

Top 20. Not far off top 10 though.

 

No

 

Nope, not for me. He still wouldn't be deserving of being thought of in such a high regard.

I've seen Enzo fight twice in the flesh and he hasn't done a great deal to impress me, although to be fair I've watched Calzaghe pretty soon after each bout.

For me, Enzo is overrated and he better up it a notch sooner rather than later.

 

Needs a few more fights, just give him some time, he won't be too far off

 

edit

 

Well I think he's getting paid £1m to take the fight, so I can see the incentive before moving up to HW

 

Haye has more to gain than you might think .

1.The WBO Cruiserweight title(okay not great considering he's moving up)
2.£1 million , that is by far his biggest purse and more than he would of got for fighting Rahman .
3.Good exposure in the UK for the first time , okay Setanta would actually have less subscribers than Sky Sports but Enzo Mac is quite well known in the UK compared to Haye who is relatively unknown .
4.Legacy , it improves his Cruiserweight legacy quite a bit .
5.Respect , he gains massive respect from hardcore fans and 99% of people will be very careful before utturing the phrase 'Haye is ducking........' from now on .
6.Just to prove to himself , Britain and the World that he indeed is the better man .

A lot of boxers wouldn't be bothered with 4/5/6 but Haye is , the guy loves to fight and loves a challenge .

 

No, he's got a good punch, but no where close to p4p material.

 

Not even close.

 

He's already beaten Mormeck in scintillating fashion (rabbit punches notwithstanding), adding rival champion Maccarinelli would make him top 15 P4P on many lists.

 

hell no