If Dawson could man up and move down in weight, why can't Alvarez?

Dude, wtf ? I already told you that Alvarez weighs 170 pounds. Thats 23 pounds. atsch
Dawson drained 18 pounds and look what happened.

 

Dude, Dawson walks around a lot heavier than the 186 pounds you imply.

---

As for the thread; there is a reason why Chad Dawson and Oscar de la Hoya are so frequently brought up for returning to divisions after 4+ years. It doesn't happen very much, let alone on the world stage where both fighters bring something to the table.

 

Dawson was 186 that night and i believe he was that most of his LHW bouts as well.
I thought if he walked around under 190 it meant he could drop some pounds without hurting his body so the dehydration would not be as heavy on his body.
atsch

Anyhow, just because Chavez Jr can drop up to 20 pounds and still be effective does not mean that every fighter can do it, especially smaller men. :-(

 

Dawson punch-resistance was shut to pieces by the weight loss. Ward isn't really a puncher.
Johnson is a better example. But then again Glen chin was iron made.

 

Wait who wants who to fight Andre Ward?!?

And if you're going to remain consistent with this stupid rehydration nonsense bull**** people are spewing about recently, than it would be a junior middleweight against a light heavyweight (Mayweather weighed 150+ fight night, Alvarez weighed 172 against Trout).

 

Floyd either fights a bigger man or not... thats all there is to it. If he claims to be a champ at LMW then by all means he should fight Canlo.

And why should Canelo drain himself ?
Double standards ?

(I dont think they should fight because it would be unfair but i would love to see it at 154.)

 

It's the way it should work since Canelo is the one chasing Floyd. But Floyd won't get any credit if he wins since he would be accused of making a guy drop down in weight so he can be drained.

What about a rehydration clause? Don't see any issues with this. Canelo shouldn't go any higher than 160-165 which is about the biggest weight Floyd's ever faced.

 

I was just speaking about Dawson weighing much more than 186 between camps.

I didn't know his fight night weight against Ward to be honest (so I really don't even understand your second statement, but I don't disagree with you or anything... nor was my post bitter if it sounded that way).

But yeah, as for JCC Jr, he's a freak like that but I think we all know how he does it (and he's been caught once before).

 

floyd will have no trouble countering canelo's attack...floyd would beat him at 154.

 

Mayweather, unless shot to pieces, beat Alvarez, with ease.

 

:good
I believe Dawson was 186 against Ward and i believed if he walked around that weight he could move down with ease. I was shocked when i saw that he rehydrated that much.

 

No one is beating someone like Canelo with ease. Canelo has speed, power, height and weight advantages. At one point size does matter. Floyd would have a thougher night then against Cotto because Canelo has a similar stile but is physically much stronger.