If Donaire wins tomorrow and then destroys Montiel..

...Are the rest of the p4p guys above him going to not fight in that time span?

 

Sidorenko is a pretty average fighter.

but if he looks impressive against Montiel, i would put him at #5 at the least.

 

hello no...but he'd be included in the top 10

 

He could maybe climb the top 10 but i doubt it.

Montiel is going to destroy him.

 

I don't think people quite understand what Montiel is capable of. Montiel's EASILY top ten now, and has been for years, the way I see it.

 

He doesn't deserve to even be in the top 10 p4p yet. One win over Darchinyan won't cut it. If he beats Montiel and Sidorenko, then we might have him in the top 10 p4p. Guys that have far better resume than Donaire aren't in yet. So he will have to earn it first.

 

Exactly dude has alot of talent and has very good power. His resume shits all over Donaire. I really dont get the hype he gets. He has talent but he fights bums really since Darchynian.

 

Since criteria for P4P doesn't really exist and everybody has a different P4P, I guess he could. YOu know what??? You don't even need to wait for that to happen. Go ahead and put him #2 in your list if that makes you happy. :roll:

 

Sidorenko is above pretty average. Dude beat Poonsawat and Agbeko. No shame in losing close decisions to Moreno. Hate saying it, but Sidorenko would become Donaire's second best name on resume. I'd say Martinez 3rd and Mthalane 4th... Donaire is a beast though.

 

Why not Donaire vs Rigondeux?

 

He is #5 in Ring already.