If GGG beats Canelo he needs to fight Ward for his legacy

Discussion in 'World Boxing Forum' started by Earfquake, Jun 26, 2017.


  1. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    Do I know you Lance? You sound like an angry fellow.
     
  2. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017


    What is this mess of a response? Can you please clean this up?

    And I dont see GGG/Canelo as a big fight because I know Canelo has 0 wins against MW's and Ive seen Golovkin fans trash him. Even just yesterday they are talking about how hes arguably lost 3 times and how he is trash. How can it be big? Because hes a big name?

    Again. Being great at boxing doesnt equate to being a big name/seller. Ward is great he doesnt sell. Golovkin is very good but without Canelo he doesnt sell.
     
  3. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    Canelo fought for the MW title at catchweight. Against a guy who won that title at a catchweight. That guy is Miguel Cotto who is a career, prime, Welterweight who on his worst day is a Jr MW because in the late stages of his career he cant cut weight to be the welter he is really is. Then Canelo defended that "title" at a catchweight against a career welterweight. That guy is the chinny joke known as Amir Khan.

    Stop and think about that for a minute. I mean really, really, think about that. Cotto and Khan are Welterweights. Thats who Canelo has fought witht that MW title. And Cotto got it from a crippled Sergio at a catchweight. Im fairly certain nobody thinks a healthy Sergio is losing to Cotto either.

    Canelo has 0 wins against MW's guy. You can dress up this pig anyway you like it. Its still a pig.
     
  4. Odins beard

    Odins beard Fentanyl is one hell of a drug.... Full Member

    20,458
    12,588
    Apr 13, 2014
    You'll be banned again soon enough Shockmaster you sad little alt.
     
    GK BOX likes this.
  5. underscore

    underscore Member Full Member

    150
    122
    Feb 14, 2017
    Fair enough, I misinterpreted
     
  6. joeyp130

    joeyp130 Active Member Full Member

    927
    247
    Dec 15, 2013

    And I agree with all that. His best win IMO is the Cotto fight. Regardless of Cottos weight history, he was THE legit MW champ at the time. And I hate this CW nonsense.

    The point I'm making, whether you agree or not, is that since that win, Canelo has taken 3 fluff fights in a row. And that's on him. He chose to fight a WW, a lightly regarded JrMW, and a SMW/LHW that hasn't been relevant in 5 years or so.

    He COULD have been fighting other ranked MWs, but chose those fights instead.

    And it would be a joke to fight for Wards LHW titles at 170.

    As far as Ward/GGG:
    When Ward was at 68 a fight with GGG at 64 is fair. Meeting in the middle. As long as the 68 titles aren't on the line.

    A CW NON title fight at 168 now is fair, since they would be meeting in the middle. If it's for the LHW titles, then heck with the CW nonsense.

    And for what it's worth, I think Ward wins.
     
    Rock0052 likes this.
  7. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    Fair post. I could agree with most of it. But is there any part of you that thinks maybe he doesnt think he would fair too well against ranked, legit, mws? And decided he better chase some money in case he gets beaten up by GGG and virtually renders himself irrelevant? Maybe he doesnt truly think he belongs in that class? When you look at his career thus far and opposition it would suggest he doesnt consider himself a MW right now. Maybe ever really.

    And I can agree about fighting for Wards titles at 170 is silly. But you cant tell me Ward being at 168 makes 164 fair. Thats garbage and moving a goal post IMO. You cant tell me now that 168 is fair when Ward moved up. But it wasnt fair when GGG was trying to sign fights at 168 and Ward was already there.

    What I think is fair is 170 with a rehydration. No belts. Its easier to put on 8 than it is to lose 8. Asking GGG to go up 8 and Dre to lose 5 is fair if you ask me.
     
  8. joeyp130

    joeyp130 Active Member Full Member

    927
    247
    Dec 15, 2013

    To me, 64 was fair at that time given that Ward was the man at 68, and GGG was the man at 60. Splitting the difference to meet at 64 is fair as long as Wards 68 titles weren't on the line. You are asking a guy who has never fought at 68 to come up and fight the dominant champ there? Not fair at all.

    168 is fair now because both guys would still be meeting in the middle. Ward being the bigger guy. But I will make this clear, if it's for a title, then the CW nonsense is out the door. I'm not a hypocrite for that standard. LHW should be no weight limit up to 175.
     
  9. dinovelvet

    dinovelvet Antifanboi Full Member

    61,244
    23,928
    Jul 21, 2012
    So you hate CWs but 164 is fair? What kind of nonsense is that?

    If meeting in the middle is fair why didn't GGG meet Brook at 154?
     
  10. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    When youve tried to make fights at 168 and say "anyone to 168" that implies youd be willing to face the "dominant champion". They simply knew making even 168 would be tough for Ward and threw out a weight he wouldnt agree on to kill any chance of the fight happening and in a sense telling Ward "move up we have no interest". K2 knew exactly what 164 meant. "Kill the fight". Ward was also coming off a nearly two year layoff and isnt known as a big, strong, puncher. 168 was fair.

    As Ward stated. When you reply back in 35 minutes you had no intention on making the fight at all. Ward said "You answer back 'no' that quickly without even saying that you will ask your fighter and get back to you. It tells you all you need to know"

    As I mentioned. Its easier to put on 8-10lbs than it is to lose 8. 170 with a rehydration for no titles is very fair. Of course its not "fair" if you just dont wanna see the fight at all.
     
  11. joeyp130

    joeyp130 Active Member Full Member

    927
    247
    Dec 15, 2013

    Either I wasn't clear or you misunderstood. My point is that the CW nonsense is BS IF a title is on the line. If a title is on the line, then that title should be fought at the limits of it's weight class.

    2 guys wanna money fight esp if they are in 2 different weight classes, and a CW is the only way to get it done, then I'm cool with that.

    I believe I have been pretty consistent. CW title fights are nonsense.
     
  12. joeyp130

    joeyp130 Active Member Full Member

    927
    247
    Dec 15, 2013

    If the fight was going to be for Wards 168 titles, then it should have been at 168. I agree with that. If it's a non title fight, just 2 guys fighting a money fight or legacy fight, then at that time, I believe 64 was fair. You are leaving out that GGG was at the time still chasing Canelo for a much bigger fight at 160. Why ruin that for a fight with Ward at 168.

    Ok..so you have clarified a fight at 170 non title fight...if that's the case I don't care..I'm not sure Ward would give up that weight. But either 170 or 175 I think Ward wins.

    And I don't think the fight happens regardless. I think GGG/,Canelo will end up and at least a 2 fight affair. And I believe Ward at his word and may look to move up again.
     
  13. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    Im not leaving that out. I know what Golovkin was holding out for. The problem is, for me anyway, that Golovkins resume STILL leaves alot to be desired. And he waited for almost 2 years for a guy that has been fighting at 147-154 his whole career. Where you see Ward went up and fough top 5 p4p guy twice. Ward already handled his first division.

    My issue stems from people saying its ok for GGG to chase Canelo. Who has 0 titles now. And won his title at a CW from a guy that won it at a CW. Canelo has 0 wins at 160. Its ok for him to chase Canelo because its a money fight. Its ok to avoid a riskier fight in Ward to keep that Canelo chance intact. But when Cotto and Canelo were passing that belt around and taking less riskier fights for big money they were called every name in the book.
     
  14. joeyp130

    joeyp130 Active Member Full Member

    927
    247
    Dec 15, 2013

    You'll get no argument from me about GGG's resume. He has tried to fight the best guys in his division. He has beaten 2 guys that MOST people rank in the top 5 of the division. And he wasn't JUST chasing Canelo. GGG earned his mandatory all the way to before Cotto. And I know you know this.

    And I don't care if Canelo has 0 wins at 160. He has 2 wins at MW with the LEGIT MW title on the line.
    There was nothing left for Ward at 168. He cleaned it out. So its better for Ward to wait around for GGG at 168 then to do what he did? Go up to 175? Ward and GGG are not even in each others realm now. Ward can clean out 175 or move up (again).

    GGG on the other hand cements his legacy and punches his ticket to the HOF by breaking Hopkin's record. That will be his legacy. He may move up after a 2 or 3 fight series with Canelo, but I wouldn't bet on it.
     
  15. Earfquake

    Earfquake Member banned Full Member

    259
    115
    Jun 20, 2017
    Thats not much of a legacy IMO Joey. Take Hopkins for example. If Hopkins retires after his MW reign he isnt nearly in the same stratosphere as he is thought of now. What he did post MW is what made Hopkins a legend. So you are attaching a name to GGGs record chase that sounds appealing. But its hollow. Hopkins opposition itself at MW is often brought into question by Golovkins own fans. Its Hopkins going up and fight Joe C and others at LHW that make him a legend.

    Ya. GGG did earn his mandatory. And he stepped aside and let Canelo and Cotto play with that belt. All in order to hope to get them in the ring. Cotto is a career, prime, Welterweight who went JR MW later in his career cuz he couldnt cut weight. At best Cotto is a JR MW. Yet this is the guy GGGs fans were calling a pansy even though GGG let him do what he did.