If Hatton beats manny pacquiao does he surpass Calzaghe in the British ATG rankings?

Thats like saying Spurs are a better team than Man Utd

 

Amazing post, once again JonOli proving your one of the biggest idiots on this board add that to being a massive Calzaghe hater.

You wouldnt know an objective post if it slapped you in the face.

 

Nearly everything you post has some sort of hidden agenda against Calzaghe such as this thread !

Im not even surprised at the poll results. Pac's wins against 2 human corpses has everyone fooled.

Answer me this jonoli, if Hatton beats Pac (Which I honestly think he will) will you class him as a better fighter than Floyd Mayweather because Hatton will have 2 wins (tszuy and pac) better than Floyd's and you said earlier you basing this on resume ??

 

Calzaghe is retired..but that hasnt put an end to JonOli's hate campaign against him. Its starting to get a little bit creepy not to mention dam right boring. Move on already!

 

Perhaps he's Froch

 

Haha

And he DENIES being a Calzaghe hater. Amazing :rofl:rofl:rofl

 

This could be an interesting debate if people put their obvious bias to one side.

Why don't we start by comparing they attributes as boxers, then their resumes and accomplishments?

For example as a starter:

Handspeed
Footwork
Strength
Adaptability
Jab
Speed
Body work
Inside work
Stamina
Workrate

 

If we're talking p4p then



Handspeed - Calzaghe
Footwork - Calzaghe
Strength - Hatton
Adaptability - Calzaghe
Jab - Calzaghe
Speed - Calzaghe
Body work - Hatton
Inside work - Calzaghe
Stamina - Calzaghe
Workrate - Calzaghe


8-2 Joe

 

Manny would be an excellent win, but a fighter well out of his best divisions.
KT was wrestled in Manchester.

KT and MP outweigh Calzaghe's opposition on paper.

But Ricky lost against Mayweather, so he wasn't the best.

Calzaghe beat all at 168, and won against bigger names at the higher weights.

I still think Joe is the best, as he won all belts at 168lbs.

Ricky also gets points deducted for not fighting Witter and for targeting easy belts, Collazo, Maussa, Urango.

Calzaghe beat Eubank, Hopkins, Roy Jones - Big names 1990's!!!
Also undefeated Kessler and Lacy.

Ricky would have to beat Manny and another good fighter at 140 and a hard champion at 147 to draw with Calzaghe.

 

He said 'putting bias to one side' :good

 

Oh well if we're putting bias to one side then that means we're not talking p4p


So 9-1 for Calzaghe as ive switched strength over to him. He'd also have advantages in height and weight

 

Because all these attributes look better when you're fighting **** opposition. Resume and accomplishments are indisputable facts.