IF Hatton had not fought floyd, were would he rank now on your p4p list

i don't think i've ever bumped him off the list.

when i've done one.

which ain't very often.

i'll do one again. :yep

1. joe calzaghe
2. manny pac
3. jmm
4. bernard hopkins
5. israel vazquez
6. antonio margarito
7. miguel cotto
8. paul williams
9. rafael marquez
10. ricky hatton

honourable mentions: pavlik, klitschko brothers, winky, mosley, abraham, john.

 

if he had't fought floyd, he wouldn't have sucked ass against lazcano. I would have him around 9 or 10

 

At 140 Top 5. Over 140 (when he fought Fraud Mayrunner) he looks pitiful.

Of course Mayweather knew this and that's why it was in the terms of the contract why else would 2 naturally smaller men fight at a higher weight?

 

You forgot the tidbit that Hatton trained down to 145 at the weigh in..:rofl:rofl so he does not add the extra bulk. He came in that fight 2 pounds away from his fighting weight. He looked like skeletor at the weigh in with Paulie. He didnt at the Floyd weigh in. No more british excuses.

 

Isn't that why they have weight classes? Hatton is a monster at 140.