I agree that Cotto would win but the atmosphere at the fight would be mint in MSG all the Brits and Ricans. Also, if it turns out Pac was that good rather than Hatton being that bad it would be a ****in' decent scrap.
I don't think he's shot physically, I have a feeling the manner in which Pac dispatched him may have mentally ruined him though.
This is a main reason why he should retire He clearly cannot fight at 140 - Did you see how drained he looked on the scales for the Pac fight? The body is saying no, his punch resistance at 140 is now terrible. The years of ballooning in weight between fights have really caught up with him.
It means he should steer clear of world class fighters. I'd like to see him fight Bradley IF he insists on fighting, I don't know who would win, Hatton prior to Mayweather would have, but he's a mess now, and was never that good anyway.