If Inoue beats Fulton, Crawford beats Spence and Usyk beats Dubois, who is pound for pound #1?

100% Inoue.

Inoue's fighting the consensus #1 and unified champ in his first fight in a new division.

 

Inoue > Crawford/Spence winner >>>>> Usyk

I would have Inoue slightly ahead of the Spence-Crawford winner because he’s been so dominant in his undisputed run at 118, and to be unified by beating the man at a 4th weight class is very significant.

Becoming undisputed at 147 is a fantastic achievement, but Spence has been so damn inactive these past few years, and Crawford has fought lower-tier opposition for years, so they can’t be ahead of Inoue.

Usyk shouldn’t be in the conversation for P4P #1 anymore, I used to be high on him but he’s so inactive with zero indications of changing that. Also, Witherspoon - Chisora - Joshua x2 - Dubois for his last 5 wins is not even close to a P4P #1 worthy run, especially when he didn’t even win all of those comfortably. It’s been 5 years since Usyk was undisputed, and all he’s done of note since then is beat Joshua (who most people on here don’t even rate highly).

 

Depends what the fights look like, but as of now would go with Monster. Usyk is near the top already but beating Dubois won’t help him any.

 

Usyk is fighting men minimum 20 lbs bigger after cleaning Cruiserweight. He’s the king until he loses or he goes on some hiatus.

 

That's tough.

Right now I have it 1) Usyk 2)Inoue 3) Crawford

But assuming these fights pan out how you said they would and the results are not controversial then my list would change to

1)Crawford 2)Inoue 3)Usyk

But it wouldn't stay like that for long because Inoue could become undisputed at 122 or win a title at 126 and Usyk could get the Fury fight.


edit: misclicked like an absolute fool. oops.

 

Usyk still. When Inoue unifies 122, he will need some good defenses or the Fury win.

Worth noting that we are comparing diamons in Inoue and Usyk, and neither Spence nor Crawford belong here.

 

It depends on how they win, but granted each wins decisively, it's probably Crawford. Spence is likely the most formidable opponent any of them have met. Also, a win for Crawford constitutes the third division he would be Lineal Champion in. That's more than Usyk and Inoue.

 

1) Inoue 2) Usyk 3) Crawford

 

Inoue for me..guys not even been pushed close yet..I know donaire got some good hits in and it was a great fight but it wasn't massively close.

I love usyk..nails road warrior...not a massive fan of his style but great at what he does...been pushed a few times but always comes out on top..needs the fury fight to cement his legacy..as does fury

Crawford....34 n no idea how good he is..passes the eye test.. competition has been pretty arse tbf...Spence fight will settle some things..woulda been better a few years ago

 

Depends on the manner of victory but in all likelihood Inoue

 

Not Usyk

 

Inoue no doubt about it.

 

Usyk/Inoue

 

Crawford belongs nowhere near p4p. His resume absolutely blows.