If JMM beats Casamayor while Calzaghe beats up a faded legend, should JMM jump to #2?

I thought I noticed a pattern last week but dont draw it to anyone's attention.
The threads are endorsed by a calzaghe fan Joecaldragon who states pacfan is not a hater thats good enough for me. I dont read too many of them because the thread title's are pretty easy to read between the lines.

Pacfan could turn out to be a nemesis for TFFP . I dont think he has enough in spreading the gospel of joe.

 

I have JMM at 2 right now because I thought he beat Pac in both fights.

 

actually i have this marquez over joe after joe's performance against hopkins. Marquez was more impressive losing by SD than joe winning an SD. And don't tell me nobody ever look impressive against hopkins, my basis for this was for all the hype and belief than calzaghe would give hopkins a one sided beatdown.

imo its just that fair jmm gets to be no.2 if he wins against casa. Casa is past his prime but clearly RJJ is about 3x more shot than hopkins or casa. Right now its the same hype and belief by fans that it would be just a walk in a park for calzaghe against jones.

P.S. Don't get that knee jerk reaction folks if calzaghe gets to KO rjj:yep

 

Only if JMM wins and Calzaghe looses.

 

Is Roy a champion coming off of a knock out victory? Over the last 3 or 4 years Casa has done a hell of a whole lot more than Roy. I don't think they're in the same boat, I don't even think they're in the same ocean.

 

No. But beating Casa would be a very good win, but seeing Casa was dominated (even though he won by SD) by Jose Armando Santa Cruz two fights ago (although Casa was rusty then), its fair to say that Casa's stock is a little overblown at the moment.

However, I would say that knocking out Casa would eclipse Pac knocking out Diaz. Diaz barely got by Ramon Montano of all people in his fight before Pac although he was clearly much more motivated for Pac.

Enough to jump Zag? No. If you are going to give him that much credit off a Casa win, you got to give everyone else insane credit for their accomplishments, so, no.

 

Joe effectively made Hopkins quit. I give him credit for that. It isn't his fault that Cortez allowed Hopkins unfair rest time due to phantom low blows. And I write this with great respect for what Hops did against Joe, Tarver, Wright and Taylor this late in his career. Just the fact that he is such a threat is a tribute to his enormous and (somewhat) age defying talents - but the old guy needed a rest and he got it.

It is a fairly close but fairly clear Zag victory although an ugly mess of a fight.

So, personally, I dismiss the posts that try and take something away from Zag for beating, or in my book, fairly clearly getting by, a guy in Hopkins who is obviously still an extremely dangerous fighter. And a guy who still hasn't been solidly beaten since Jones a million years ago - and even then he delivered a very good performance.

 

He does not actually have to beat casa coz in the books of divac, JMM is already #1 p4p..

 

I give a flying **** about P4P rankings, just as any purist of the sport should'nt

 

Casa is near shot, he struggled past Kasidis...which is shocking.

Neither JMM nor Calzaghe are top 5 P4P now.

 

Wow you have a short memory? Everybody and their grandma picked Katsidas to beatdown the "shot" Casa, and we know how that went.....Casa's KO over Katsidas is an easy KO of the year candidate....Hows that for "shot"? ****ing meathead

 

Pac beats jc in terms of speed. Jc punches like jigglypuff.