If Jmm whips Manny in this fight..would you be mad if Floyd rematched him?

so dodong how would a fight between the JMM that fought Pac in November 2011 go against welterweight Floyd?

 

A Juan who isn't in the worst condition of his life should do better, specially against a slowing down Mayweather, that's basic logic *****. Juan would still lose most probably (Juan is still too small and it's a bad matchup for him, style wise), but it'd be a far more competitive fight

They meant a lot, they meant Mayweather sat on his ass while Marquez had to almost kill himself to make weight

That's why catchweights suck, making weight when there's so much size disparity distracts you a lot from actual training, specially when it's the first time, and specially when the opponent ain't doing ****. It cant get more unfair than that

 

Floyd relies a lot on his reflexes while Jmm doesn't. I think a rematch would be closer as the fight will be fought more stationary instead of Floyd darting in and out like a cat but Floyd still clearly wins. But Jmm would have more success imo.

 

it may again turn out exactly the same again but if jmm does beat pac and jmm ask for a rematch, he deserves one.

physical appearance alone indicates jmm got bigger and stronger.

 

Floyd won the first fight by a margin of 120-107, if JMM wins one round clearly that would mean the rematch would have been closer, that's not really saying much.

 

How much credit would you give mayweather if he beats Juan the same way?

 

I think it would be 8-4 ish for the reasons already mentioned in this thread. Floyd's key assets are/were his speed and reflexes to go along with his amazing skills and mind. But you take a lot of that speed and reflexes away and he's easier to track down. He didn't let Cotto tag him multiple times on purpose. He simply doesn't have the legs he used too.

 

Fair enough sir, I think Pac wins the 4th fight clearly, I have no reasons or analysis for thinking that,just a feeling I got.

 

top 2-3 of his best win...that is if jmm completely dominates and ko's pac.

 

Too easy of a fight for Floyd, IMO. A fight with Canelo would be more appealing.

 

At this stage, I think Manny would still be the tougher stylistic challenge than JMM. That fight takes precedent due to the historicity. The size factor makes the style factor that much harder for JMM still even if he is more acclimated to the weight.

 

I doubt it. But yes, it's like Manny fighting Morales, Barrera, JMM over and over and over. How can you be an ATG if you keep fighting guys you know you can beat? Pac-Morales IV is around the corner I'm sure.

 

I wouldn't be surprised if he does. There are no options out there for Mayweather except moving up to 160 for Martinez. There's no way in hell Arum would give away Bradley to Mayweather.

 

marquez was shot when he fought floyd. And has become unshot again.

Floyd is ducking a prime Marquez, and that is a fact.