If Joe C. would, have fought James Toney, who would win?

This content is protected

 

Again, comparing Calzaghe with Toney's opponents does absolutely nothing to justify your opinion than Toney would win.

 

This content is protected

 

It's fine to compare competition, but it's not the best way to go when analyzing a fantasy matchup.

The best way to go is to examine how Toney and Calzaghe would perform against eachother and how the two styles would gel in the ring.

 

I actually predicted Toney would KO Nunn in a come from behind victory. Toney was an angry fighter back then. Those guys were keeping him from gorging him self on fast food and junk food.

 

This content is protected

 

All valid points...what ever works I guess:good

 

Fighting Weight shouldnt even be able to post in here..he's the most biased ****er there is.

Calzaghe got stunned by a uppercut from Kessler..he's acting like he was ready to be taken out from it. atsch

 

I suggest you watch it again....he backed off and then held. What I said was a better fighter than Kessler would have not let the opportunity slip.

 

Toney doesn't have a jab and Calzaghe's defence is better? :huh
I'm speechless.

and what do you mean by dynamic?

who has Joe fought apart from Kessler? And we don't even know his true level yet.
He's fought **** all.

 

We know his true level

A level above James Toney, as displayed in this poll

I was on a wind up with the defence. That's about the only thing he does better than Calzaghe

 

the poll is dead level.
and that's only because you opened about 20 accounts on here


In my opinion Calzaghe's standing will depend on what Kessler goes on to do.
we know Eubank was faded and weight-drained, Lacy has been confirmed very average and Sheika was B level at best.

 

Kessler will go on to do a lot, in my opinion, so I'll settle for that

Joe has 2 fights left anyway, which will confirm his greatness

 

agreed on Kessler.

I pick Toney UD over Calzaghe, Toney could not afford to be anything less that fully prepared though.