If Manny and Floyd retired tomorrow who is P4P #1

JMMarquez.

 

if rafael marquez beats lopez it would definitely be him!

 

no manny retires in this scenario. silly.

 

****! :huh I'd say Paul williams but that would be highly debated and I would understand.

 

I'd say if Ward beats Dirrell easily, he deserves a shout

 

Im no fan, but how people dont rate Wlad K in the top 10 P4P i will never know, what can someone do than completely dominate a division(even though weak), defend his heavyweight titles on god knows how many occasions

 

The thread is a good one and actually refreshing b/c of all the PAC and Floyd threads. So Props to you for switchin things up.

But Paul I think has the most potential. He's operating at a high level between 3 weight divisions and he's only lost once. But all those other names are quality guys. Very hard to predict who would take over that spot.

 

Based on talent alone, Rigondeaux, Gamboa or Donaire. Based on both I think JMM if he stays at 135?

In the near future I think it'll be either Ward, Donaire, Dawson, Rafa. I think Lopez gets derailed by Marquez. Donaire has a good shot since I think its pretty certain he beats Montiel this sept.

 

Ah forgot about Wlad. Yea I agree, based on dominance alone and scaring Haye away I think the guy has a very strong claim. Nobody comes close but his brother.

 

either chad dawson if he beats pacal convincingly or wlad or bhop

i cant choose definitively at this point

 

Paul Williams