who will be number 1 p4p... and will the debate over it force these 2 into a fight ? i know its hypothetical, but if they both look good in victory, how will this set up a future fight & their p4p status' ???
Neither will win. Case closed. They wil both wear the ass-whippin of a lifetime. Shane and Clottey will fight for the undisputed title.
Id say If Mayweather beats Shane that he would be p4p 1.. Basically because Mosely is arguably p4p1 atm. Also, Floyd would be beating a better opponent than Pac. But, I do see that there could be an argument from those who rate Pac p4p 1 at the present and that he would have to be beaten for him to lose that status. Opinions would no doubt be divided as to who you favour as a fighter, thats about all that splits being p4p 1 atm.
How is Shane better p4p then Pac. Now I will admit many will say Mosley is a better WW and that may very well be true but there is no way he is better p4p.
Mayweather of course. Mayweather becomes my own personal number 1 upon singing the contract to fight Mosely (although tards and Pac fans alike will disagree strongly, of course) I won't rate a fighter number 1 when they clearly duck the biggest and best fight out there (at the time AND of their whole career) and turn around to face Clottey (good, not great) - while the other guy turns around and faces a higher ranked (and champion) welterweight currently in most peoples top 5 pound for pound. Especially when that fighter (Pac) was given the title (p4p) upon the retirement of the other fighter (Floyd) only.
imo.... whoeva has more ppv buys..will get the larger purse..no more 50/50..... and the p4p #! at the time....
If Pac can do more numbers against Clottey than PBF can do against Shane - he deserves more than 50%. Chances of that happening are very minimal, however.
If Pacquiao wont submit to random tests, then a Mayweather win against anyone is a loss for Pacquiao.
simple answer mayweather of course and very obvious at that he just beat p4p no.2 and if he beats p4p 3 he is no.1 no doubt, pac's only good win was cotto, clottey is good but cotto already beat him on paper plus clottey ain't rated p4p top 10