If Mayweather has agreed to accept the same Olympic style testing....

Rudyard · Dec 23, 2009

rushman said: ↑

If Floyd makes an unreasonable request, it doesn't suddenly become reasonable just because he also agrees to do it.

Lets test the basic premise of this argument "If Floyd is willing to do X then it is reasonable to demand that Pac do X also"

So, if Floyd is willing to have pictures of himself taken, where he is naked and has a used condom hanging out of his butt, and have these published for free in a gay magazine, then it is fair that he demands Pacman do the same thing.

Clearly this is wrong. So the basic premise is wrong too. The only way to fix this is if you change your basis premise. But then you strike huge problems.

The basic premise that your argument has to use instead is this: ""If Floyd is willing to do X - AND it there is no single other reason for Pac not to do X - then it is reasonable to demand that Pac do X also"

Here is where people are becoming unstuck. Cause they all think they know whether Pac has a good reason or not.
Click to expand...

:gayfight

Log in or Sign up

If Mayweather has agreed to accept the same Olympic style testing....

Rudyard How You Feel!! HOE! banned

Log in or Sign up

Forums

If Mayweather has agreed to accept the same Olympic style testing....

Rudyard **** How You Feel!! HOE! banned

Rudyard How You Feel!! HOE! banned