If Miguel Cotto blows Antonio Margarito out of the water.

Anything else besides being impressed cannot be an answer.

Although I think Cotto will win IMPRESSIVELY, I don't think he'll be blowing anyone out of the water. Some have tipped it, so fair enough, their answer may be different to mine. But most think it'll be a good, tough fight with Cotto winning (GENERALLY, although some think otherwise)

 

If Cotto blows Margarita he's p4p #1.

 

Cotto's stock would have to significantly rise, even though it's already very high. Like you said Margo's as tough as they come, and a belt holder in the stacked WW division.

 

atsch

 

Assuming he gives him a beating, as you say, a Mayweather v Gatti type performance, I'd be mightily impressed. To overcome that much power, height, workrate and chin would be some accomplishment. Unlikely though. Margarito's no Gomez.

 

:think

I'd be fairly impressed but far from surprised, Cotto has great tools and above average skill and knowlege of the game he already knows what he needs to do to win so its merely a matter of concentration and proper execution.

 

I'd be ****ing amazed! and I'd definitly put Cotto hight up on the P4P list.

 

That would be very impressive because i don't see any fIghter doing that to Margarito.

 

I would consider Cotto the best Welter weight today, its very unlikely but I would also like to add that if Cotto did blast Tony out of there well I am sure in six months Floyd Mayweather will be fighting Tony

 

Cotto gets P4P respect and becomes the man at 147. No other answer would suffice.

 

I think Tony's too tough and too good to get blown out (I don't even know if Cotto will win) but if it happened I put Cotto in my top four P4P.

 

I wouldn't have him in front of the top 5. But he'd be from 6-10. Now if he takes the Williams-Quintana belt and whoever holds the IBF strap then yes, he starts making an argument for the top 3.