If Miguel Cotto blows Antonio Margarito out of the water.

It would be tough to put him past Pac-Man or Calzaghe. Although I suppose Pac-Man could also lose to Diaz.

 

Just wondering how many here will give Margarito the same props should he dominate Cotto.

Would he then be ranked high on PFP lists:think

 

yea if Cotto beats Margarito like he beat Gomez then he's number 1 in my book.

but he won't

 

Who's your top 5?

 

He'd have to, won't he! Cotto is a consistent performer who is getting better with every fight. If Margarito beats Cotto, it means he's really, really good!

He won't, though. He just doesn't have enough, I don't think.

 

Margarito sometimes gets cut. Anyone can be hurt to the body, even tough Mexicans like Margarito. He's not good enough a boxer to avoid that many of Cotto's hurtful punches, like Mosley did, for example. He'll have to make it a war to win, so he'll take a lot of leather. I wouldn't be that surprised if Cotto stops him...:think

 

I agree.

 

there's a difference between stopping someone and dominating him from pillar to post like Cotto did to Gomez.

 

Sure; however, I was speaking of a possible stoppage.

Anyway, Cotto has the right stuff to dominate Margarito, even if not to the same extent he dominated Gomez...we'll see.

 

Margo will win by KO in rd 7

 

Stoppage or Knockout?

 

I'll put it in my top 4 P4P list and at welterweight #1. He deserves to be #1 at welter.IMO

 

I would be very impressed and say he goes higher on the p4p rankings. I think p4p is taken too seriously though.

I think Cotto wins a decision, but takes his lumps in the process. 8-4 type fight.