if Pac beats Oscar, is he a GREATER fighter than Floyd?

Pac would only be doing what PBF has already done. He'd be doing to a older Oscar than Floyd beat. Albeit coming from an even lower weight.

 

Absolutely

 

Too many if's for me surrounding Floyd's legacy according to his fanboys

 

One thing that can't be an if is He was undefeated. Linear in 3 weights title holder in 2 P4P #1 for 3 years top 10 P4P for 10 years ring fighter of the year for 1998 and 2007 never knocked down or really hurt in a fight and one of the best fighters of his era and would school Pac in a fight like he did the man in your avatar.:deal

 

:good Definitely, but he was officially knocked down, but not legitimate so I sort of agree, he's been buzzed but to me that's more impressive than never really been buzzed since it has been very rarely and he handled it better than most fighters. He is one of the best fighters of his era and the runner up to be considered the best and although he did school the guy in my avatar (both of them ironiaclly) I think we should wait and see how Pacquiao does at welter before we conclude that a retired fighter would schoold him as well as he did to Hatton.

 

in terms of resume maybe
in terms of skill level no

 

IMO he's already greater as well

meaning he's proves it time in and out against the odds

 

No ****ing way.:nono JMM had Pac all over the place and he's no where in PBF' league as far as counter-punching, speed or defense. PBF would eat a come foward guy like Pac with no defesne and no jab for lunch. PBF would counter the hell outta Pac and have him clueless as to how to solve this puzzle with his ring generalship, movement and defense. PBF's superior to Pac in everything if both were the same size except power he gets a boxing lesson period.

 

Fair enough. That knock down was bull**** against Hernadez because PBF took a knee after hurting his hand after throwing a punch.

 

Bull**** Name em! Pac nuthuggers maybe but that's it. The ring most definitely didn't and neither did ESPN as well as any other reputable sources.:deal

 

PBF had a strategy going into that fight with Zab and that was Zab is a front runner he's no good after 6 rounds or so and that's what PBF did. He split the first 4 rounds with Zab and then systematically broke Zab down over the course of the fight he executed his gameplan to perfection and would have stopped Zab if not for the low blow in the 10th. Horrible comparison.

BTW JMM has given Pac fits with his style often outboxing him at will. PBF is much better than JMM and would do it as well but wouldn't be bothered by his speed as much because he has much better defense and chin and can answer back with his own blazing speed with accuracy.