If Pac is so GREAT why then....

For one fight against a **** opponent? Well done. It was common knowledge Floyd gave away a tonne that night. I thought you were going to provide evidence on all of his fights above 140.

And my last post ends your feeble argument anyway.

 

So because he weighed 149 against Baldomir it does not count?


:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl


You're a joke.

 

Yawn. It counts, but one fight is not proof that Mayweather always weighs in at 149, is it? And as I've already said, giving away weight to a punchbag like Baldomir is completely different to giving it away to a p4p ranked proven quality welterweight.

Once Floyd has done that, then you have a case! Till then: You don't. :hi:

 

146 against Judah

This content is protected

 

Hatton?

Oscar?

Also, didn't Cotto knock Judah the **** out?? :?

 

Pac cheats on his wife.

 

Hatton and Oscar weren't shown.


Cotto took 11 rounds and 2 low blows to stop Judah.

Judah had not fought in a year and had not won in two years prior.

 

Hatton and Oscar weren't shown. How convenient.

That's enough to stop you saying Floyd always weighs 149 though, as you have no proof of that. :good

Cotto KTFO Judah, because Judah (like Baldomir, like Sharmba Mitchell, and like Hatton) was not and is not on the same level at 147 as Cotto, Williams, Mosley and Margarito - four fully-fledged ww's that Floyd did not fight in his time at 147.

Once Floyd does fight a top-class ww and gives away 10-12lbs, THEN you can say "so should Pac".

Until then, Fail!

Class dismissed. Goodnight gentlemen of ESB.


(PS: cheers for the Tyson-Oscar stats on the other thread, I didn't know that!)

 

Like I said before earlier to someone else. A Hatton fan said on the UK televised version that Hatton was 154 and Floyd was 149.

On top of it, Mayweather said he was 146 for Marquez already, then like 2 weeks later someone made a thread about seeing Floyd weigh in at 145 at a gym.

Let's look at when Floyd fought Baldomir.

2006, 11-04 Baldomir Floyd happens.

Mosley takes the rest of 2006 off. He admits to such.

Williams had beat Mitchell prior (this qualifies as a shot at Mayweather?) He fought on the Baldomir-Mayweather undercard.

Cotto - This is the best one. Cotto had yet to fight at 147 when Mayweather fought Baldomir.

After this, Mayweather went to fight the two biggest fights back to back that the people wanted to see.

I have to disagree. He already weighs 145/146.

:good

 

A fan of Hatton said something, and Floyd himself said something too?

Why didn't you reveal this concrete proof earlier!?!

Could've saved us all a lot of time and bother.

Yawn. Adios.

 

If Pac said he was weighing 145. Would you not believe him?

 

manny's a great fighter, there's no denying that, but to cement his legacy he needs to take care of business with jmm or beats floyd he's gonna be known for losing to past his prime erik morales and beating old ass oscar and losing twice to jmm and getting a gift decision on the second fight. the rest are credible and spectacular wins, but c'mon guys, it's pretty clear if a past it marco antonio barerra won the trilogy vs. erik it was no surprise manny destroyed erik. i wasn't even sure erik was going to be able to beat manny that first time but he did. manny's simply cashing in, hell, who the hell wouldn't?

 

And for my very final trick:

Now goodnight!!

 

Claim he the biggest draw is not the same and as saying he's down to 146 already.

But whatever. You've admitted that if Floyd weighs the same as Pac then its fair.

 

If Floyd fights a p4p ranked proven top quality welterweight and gives away weight, then you can say Pac should do it too.

Until then, you have no argument. :hi: