He's overrated because some people thought he was up there with guys like Whitaker, SRL, etc in the ATG list.
Anyone who isn't an idiot can see this is a great win. You're basically asking the group of people who for one reason or another want to discredit a Marquez win to tell you why, when the only real answer to that is that they wanna hate on him, its a loaded question.
Its a great win because a great fighter beat another great fighter but going by this board, it seems as though JMM beat a cab driver last Sat.
Floyd is over rated by some....so are the Klitchkos...Pac too...but most rate them in the proper perspective. Pac was fighter of the decade for a reason....it was based on who he beat and how he beat them and Pac had an amazing run. Pac is a legit ATG and former P4P king. You can't take away something Pac earned just becuase you don't like him.
Let me go on record and say that Bradley is not great and never will be. He is just a solid good fighter. He does not posess the attributes of greatness. Packie is above average but not great. His aggression, speed and power puts him a notch above the average good fighter. Marquez is great because he has reached the status of master. He has mastered the art of the counterpunch. There is no one better in the game today and his skills can be judged against fighters throughout history and will be deemed worthy. You add that to his dedication, his technical skill, his mental approach, his grit, his personality and his power. Most, which are elite and all above average. The man is a great fighter.:bbb
People act like countering and out-boxing Pacquiao is the norm because he has a few losses against other ATG's.
Pac was not outboxed, he was out thought. He neglected the one thing he needed in the heat of battle and thats his ability to think. He was just reacting when JMM caught him tripping and knocked him the **** out.:bbb