If Pacquiao beats Spence, is he the GOAT?

What fighter in their prime did Floyd beat that was better than Barerra?

 

I said Spence had never fought anyone outside of a shot and damaged Brook. He's since added to his resume nicely and has Porter, Mikey, and Danny on it.

 

He'll say canelo at 23... who's claim to fame at the time was a close fight w/ A Trout. A guy who didn't do much else in his career.

 

No I didn't. Jeff said that as natural as can be and without hesitation. And then he remembered he was a Mayweather giving that interview in the Mayweather Boxing Gym.

 

Just because he's had close fights with JMM doesn't mean that it's not considered a great win regardless. I can say the same about Ali beating Norton x2, Canelo beating GGG, or SRL beating Hagler but just because some people don't agree with the results doesn't mean it shouldn't count. They're all considered great wins and Pac officially beat JMM twice and history will see it as a great win.

Not sure why these losses, especially his early losses aainst Torrecampo and Singsurat have to be held against him when so many ATGs of the past have also had losses early on like Ezzard Charles, Arguello, Armstrong, Gavilan, Hopkins, etc. They're irrelevant and many ATGs go through bad losses along the way, it happens. It doesn't make them any less of a great fighter, much like Pac.

And no, I never said that Pac ranks above SRL. Despite how you see Pac's ranking he certainly has an argument as being a Top ATG. It's all subjective at the end of the day.

 

Get out of here with this lazy ass ****. I'm talking real stuff here, none of those fighters were ATGS. When you're accessing and comparing greatness especially GOAT level stuff you will be picked apart. If your best win is MAB and another guy who's in the running for GOAT has a win over Duran like SRL does and then you add in others like Benitez, Hearns and Hagler and he doesn't have a bad loss like Torrecampo and a faded Erik Morales and Horn well that little bull**** you posted looks pretty dumb and lazy now doesn't it? Explain to me smart ass how Pac is greater than SRL who's not even a top 10 ATG, when he doesn't have the resume to back it up. Now refute that or log off fanboy.

 

@Pimp C

You have said REPEATEDLY stated that...

1) Pac will never take the fight

2) Pac has zero shot of winning

And 3), Spence will brutalize and retire Pac.

So you're not gonna call a 42 year old midget doing the impossible worthy of GOAT status?



What impossible fights did SRR win?

 

Yes

& if you don't understand why you DKSAB

42 year old who started out at minimum weight beating a prime a fully fledged Welterweight of Spence's calibre?

Miraculous.

 

The difference is those fighters who had those loses all had wins against fighters better than MAB so that helped make up for losses unlike Pac. If you want to say he beat JMM then fine it's in the record books as a win but then you have to ask yourself how great was JMM, he's what a top 75 ATG if that???

 

You're right... No one will call Lewis, Ali, or Pac ATG's. Man...you insecure little man-child. You've always worried more than anyone here about what fans think. Freakin man-child cry baby....

 

I said Pac would never fight Crawford and I said before Spence got hurt that he wouldn't fight Spence. It was only after Spence got hurt that people like you begin talking about him fighting Spence. Before that you were quiet as a church on Tuesday when Spence's name was mentioned about fighting Pac. Funny it takes an life threatening accident to bring out the bravery in people.

 

Spence came back and already beat Danny Garcia you idiot.... Man...meth has ruined your brain...

 

Duran's resume isn't as good as Pacman's if you just compare the total number of big names both have fought and winning those fights, however Duran's win over SRL in his prime does Trump the best win on Pacman's resume by a country mile.

I believe if Pacman beats Spence it'll be a feat on par with Duran beating Barkley if not better.

 

Thanks for bowing out when you know you're in too deep. Like I said you can't refute my point about Pac being > SRL because you already know that he's not and SRL is not even a TOP 10 ATG yet you get mad and want to argue with me for pointing that out and saying Pac isn't the GOAT because you're a Pac fanboy and don't like me saying it. Find someone else to play with because you're done here.

 

Duran and Leonard are a league above Pac.

But they are also a league above Mayweather.