If PBF fought Mosley's resume he'd have 7 losses!

They might be who knows?
Shane is very flawed and never did look like the same fighter who fought at 135 when he moved up. He can't make adjustments, has poor defense and tries to beat people with his speed that wouldn't be enough against PBF. I would favor PBF to beat Shane at 147 prime for prime.
Oscar is somewhat closer because of his jab but back then he was even more of a one-handed fighter and PBF is too smart to get beat by one hand. Just like when they fought at 154 he neutralized Oscar's left hook, prime for prime it would be no different.. Not to mention Oscar had troubles against speed and defense see the Shane and Pea fights for reference. He would lose the championship rounds to PBF who comes on strong the later the fight goes because he's a throwback 15 round fighter. I would favor PBF to beat Oscar at 147 prime for prime.

 

How the hell is Cotto too small? And he certainly isn't "too slow".

 

:good

 

7 losses? No. I would think at least 2 though.

 

Nonsense. You have to look at who Shane fought (win or lose) and ask yourself if Floyd would still be undefeated had he faced the same competition.

 

Who knows. What we do know is that Mosley is going to get his brains scrambled on May 31st.:good

 

Shane may have scrambled brains from all the celebrating that will be taking place after he sends Judah back to ESPN FNF.:good

 

Alright, that was classic. I have no comeback for now.

 

mosley took something to keep him fresh against de la hoya in those late rounds.

 

little tip...

dont include carlos baldomir in anyones resume if you are trying to make their resumes look impressive.

 

What he gains in defense, he gives up in offense. You can't have it both ways.

 

Dumb thread.

PBF might beat DLH. He beat a past his best De la Hoya and could be the prime version also.

Vernon Forrest over PBF? :rofl

Prime Wright would have beaten Mayweather. However, Wright is a 154-160 fighters, much bigger than Mayweather.

I think Floyd would beat Cotto.

 

I agree 100 percent

 

HAHAHAHAHAH Genaro nothing special? HAHAHA. You should never post again with you ****ing ******ed bias statements.

 

1. Grossly is an over statement. Do you know how much each exactly weighed fight night?
2. That is nothing new. Oscar moved up to fight and beat a priem Whitaker and a prime Castillejo too. Infact Many fighters have moved up and won. Nothing out of the ordinary.
3. As if PBF didn't have any advantages. I rather have speed over ring size, I rather have youth over glove brands, I rather have reflexes over giving over 7 pounds.
4. PBF never even bruised DLH's face let alone hurt him. PBF landed two meaningful shots in the entire fight as he refused to engage.
5. PBF knew he had to fight or should I say be in defensive mode 95% of the time other wise he would be beat up, it's hard to hurt someone who is unwilling to test his own limits. PBF only took one chance to show greatness and that was in the last 3 seconds of the entire fight. and he had his nose busted up and his head bobbled around. Only in the last 3 seconds did he choose to atempt to hurt DLH.