If Roy Jones KOs Tito then Beats Winner of......

ROFL. Hill an ATG? Especially one that wasn't even motivated after getting his ass whooped by Hearns and DM?

Keep dreaming, kid. Preschool is thatoway.

:deal

 

As i said before Pawel, always have to put in something ******ed at the end of a post.

Is Shane Mosley an ATG? or Winky Wright?

 

Hill is not an ATG, Toney basically was at that point and Hopkins was just coming into his own, not close to being an ATG yet.

Roy is an ATG, probably top 40-50, just not a top 25 ATG.

If he were to easily outpoint Calzaghe or KO him, it would help his cause but cracking the top 15 or even 10 would be a HUUUUGE stretch!

The fight with Tito serves no meaning to me.

 

Shane is top 75 based on his run in the lightweight division and the big Oscar win.

Winky is top 100.

 

Both Mosley and Wright would be on the threshold, depends on your criteria.

But Hill is most definitely not an ATG. To even hint that he is says something about your lack of knowledge concerning boxing.

 

What have they done that is better than what Hill did?

 

atsch atsch atsch atsch atsch atsch atsch atsch atsch

They actually beat other elite fighters?

 

Thank you RZA!

 

hahahah. The first guy to bring up that point was kg0208. He have a lack of boxing knowledge?

Hill won world titles in 2 weight class's, and had 20 LHW title defences. Just because a guy is under the radar does not mean that he is not good.

 

:good

 

Mosley beat Oscar and Winky beat Mosley. So by the power of that they are obviously much better than Hill? With 20 LHW title defences and belts in 2 weight class's?

 

Titles in multiple division and title defenses do not make you an all-time great... That's why no one cared about Hopkins pre-Tito.

To be an all-time great, you need to defeat great fighters. Who was Hill's best win? Maske?

 

Because they actually have an elite name in the "W" column?

What happened when Hill faced DM or Jones?

 

That logic is flawed to hell. So are Tito or Oscar ATG MW's?

 

Not to mention that Wright cleaned out 154 and Mosley dominated the lightweight division for years.