If Roy Jones KOs Tito then Beats Winner of......

Ahh i get you now.... :nut

 

If pigs could fly, they wouldnt get slaughtered.

 

RJJ is already a top 5 all time for natural talent ! As far as accomplishments go...he would definitely be a top 10 !!

Its quite possible it happens..just watch !

 

Indeed. It will not happen but I would love to see it as a Jones fan. But Calzaghe wins a UD now comfortably at that.

 

You can't get ktfo'd by Glencoffe Johnson and be the G.O.A.T. no matter what you do.

 

Give the man a break. He would have beat Glen Johnson like a drum in his prime. Also what if he stepped up and beat Wlad?

 

You know of course that Trinidad isn't even close to the greatest Jr MW ever. Off the top of my head, Hearns, McCallum, and Norris beat him.

As for the criteria for an ATG, Hill is deserving of consideration. Chavez actually never to my estimation beat another ATG. He beat the top fighters in his weight classes at the time, but not ATG's. Hill beat many top LHW's but no ATG's. Same with Calzaghe, who many are giving consideration as an ATG now, though he has never beaten nor faced one.

Point is, the criteria seems to change as needed. Mosley beat an ATG (One) but he also never had a run at any weight class he's been in that Hill did.

BTW, Jones can no longer beat Calzaghe.

 

Joens has no chance against Joe who is a dead cert to prevail against Hopkins. It simply can't happen, a prime Jones would have been something to behold and would have at least offered competition but this Jones?

Highly questionable. Plus lets not fogrget this is Roy Jones here, he talks and walks.

Away.

 

Yeah......aren't you one of the guys thinking Klitscho could be an ATG if he keeps winning?

 

No. Im one of the guys who think he's already an ATG.

 

Well done then, everybody is intitaled to there own opinion :good. Wont argue with you other than to say I disagree.

 

So in your estimation, you cannot get stopped by Johnson past your prime after winning titles in 4 weight classes and be P4P Top 3 for 10 straight years and be an ATG, but you can be stopped by Ross Purrity, Corey Sanders, and Lamon Brewster, 2 of them in his prime?

 

Which is fine. My argument is application of standards....and the apparent double standard he is using.

 

Yep. It is just a crazy notion at this point. People with crazy notions usually are not good to have a debate with.

 

:good