If they retire today, How would you rank Johnson, Tarver, Haye, Adamek and Dawson

Tarver- 1st real Jones conqueror Ring LHW Champ Win over Johnson.
Johnson-50 wins been around forever almost like a modern Archie Moore getting his title late in life beating Tarver and has continued to fight but keeps coming up short.
Haye and Adamek tie- Both 2 weight champs both ring magazine cruiser champs and both compete at hwt with success right now
Dawson-still building a name for himself despite 5 big wins against Tarver Johnson and Adamek

 

1.Adamek
2.Haye
3.Chad Dawson
4.GLen Jhonson
5.Tarver

 

haye
dawson
adamek


johnson
tarver

 

Snap

Tarver got lucky with his timing.

 

Adamek
Haye
Dawson
Tarver
Johnson

 

Tarver and Johnson are history, Adamek got sth to do in HW , both with Haye should prove their ability to fight in HW, Dawson is probably the greatest from this list but he also need to prove it

 

This is ridiculous...doesn't Dawson own wins over three of these guys? Ok, we won't include past it Tarver and Johnson, but how can you put Adamek over Dawson when Dawson beat Adamek???

 

So if your judging is like this we should put Zahir Raheem over Erik Morales in p4p rankings,because he beat Morales.

 

Because he moved up and became CW champ? He has two good wins at HW too now.

 

Dawson
Adamek
Haye
Johnson
Tarver

 

Against who? I'm not trashing Adamek and his accomplishments but who has he really beaten? Pascal and Cunningham were ok but what have they done?

 

Morales was on the down slide and out of his natural weight...Dawson and Adamek were roughly the same age, size, and experience. I'm just saying Dawson has a better resume and owns a win H2H.

 

Against bigger guys.

 

That's how I would rank them.