If you were a SM, would you fight Calzaghe or RJJ?

That video does make Calzaghe look really bad

 

Fighting/beating RJJ at this point in his career proves nothing.

I picked Calzaghe, but I also believe fighting/beating a retired fighter that is relatively old and inactive does not prove anything(much).

 

prime roy jones would be much harder. his speed was damn near impossible to touch.

 

jones because he has no chin, can't adapt in the ring, and collapses like a lawn chair when faced with adversity. if you lose to jones, theres always a chance he will fail the banned anabolic steroid drug tests afterwards.

 

As of now...I would pick RJJ. He can't pull the trigger to save his life

Prime though I'll stay the **** away from him at all cost

 

Considering Roy had a good chin in his prime, I'd go with Calzaghe. Both were excellent, but Joe had tough moments, whereas Roy had none. I'd also rather get beat down by Joe Calzaghe than Roy Jones.

 

easier to deal with slaps from calzaghe then pure spped and accuracy from jones

 

Your question translates to "who was more beatable at their peak, Jones or Calzaghe?". And I can't ****ing beleive 8 people think it is Calzaghe. They obviously have no clue what Roy Jones was like.