manassa very good post ,but could i ask you a question would bratton of faired any better against pryor not winding you up just intersted in your opinion as pryor could of moved up to welter without any problem
Nah, I doubt it. Bratton was good, but Pryor had a special something that would drive him to victory against most contenders in history, although I do think his abilities are sometimes blown out of proportion. But then maybe Bratton would be slippery enough to take a points decision - but I wouldn't bank on it. Pryor by decision or late stoppage, just an obtuse, attritional hammering that Bratton wouldn't be able to avoid. But then I think Ike Williams would take Pryor.
YEAH THAT I KNOW i must say though i also think pryor vs beau jack would of ended with pryor stopping jack and i still say pryor would have a good shot at beating williams but then match-ups like these are always going to have people disagreeing that is what makes it interesting for me anyway
i think he would of managed it fine but it would of been the highest he could of gone and been competative
Just to update this thread. 1:59 to 2:18 - see Williams sliding out of range and pivoting around Jack. He does this constantly throughout the fight and leads Jack onto his uppercuts, weakening him by the fifth round. 3:05 - proof of the effect of those punches is telling, and Williams senses it. He lowers his hands, avoids Jack's fading shots and tears him up at close range. [yt]YpQU81leuXg&NR=1[/yt] It's this kind of stuff that makes me think Williams would do a job on Henry Armstrong.
Jack is perpetually coming in ala Armstrong ,but he does not have the head movement ,or the cross arm ,elbows in, defence of Hank and his punches are much wider.Armstrong threw punches from a much lower stance ,because he was shorter,but more than that ,he remained in his crouch, head down,Jack is often open when he is throwing. Jack advances bends his knees,then fires off a wide hook usually a left, but by then Williams has tagged him with a couple of jabs and is in position to check him with either a short inside hook ,or an uppercut. You can see here Jack is beginning to run purely on heart ,whereas Williams ,to mis- quote Hagler has only used a couple of tools from his box. Ive allways thought Williams beats Duran,and Armstrong.Perversely,Mayweather might just out box Ike,I dont think so ,because his legs arent as swift as his other natural talents ,he relies a lot on upper body movement to avoid shots .Williams could be outboxed ,but you needed fast feet to do so imo.
There's nothing I disagree with here, I thought you were picking Armstrong and that I'd have something to refute but you didn't.
great thread guys! just popped in as i'm an ike fan and wanted to see the clip but all the posts so far have been great and very informative!
Sorry to dis- abuse you,[I like the sound of that]. I am pissed,but, irrespective of that. And much as it pains me to concede it, you are undoubtedly the best interpreter of a fight ,I have seen on this forum. My respects.
I think FMJ has quick enough feet certainly at SFW he was quick on his feet, very quick watch the Gennaro Hernandez fight to see. I'd agreee on the picks though Duran and Hank but i think FMJ nicks it. Mannasa is always a joy to read and a brillaint , as you say, interpreter of a fight hes fluent in boxing
We normally cut a bit of slack for great fighters who started picking up losses as their career wound down. Here, we allow the same slack for Williams. When Williams lost to Jimmy Carter he was already past his best, but we'll use that as the cut off point; just like Willie Pep's is the Saddler loss, Ray Robinson's is the Turpin loss and Ezzard Charles' is the Walcott defeat. Going into that fight, Williams' record stood at 118-16-4. Up to that point, he had beaten the following fighters, all of whom were at one time or another rated in the RING's top ten at featherweight, lightweight or welterweight: Lefty LaChance (x2) Wes Mouzon Slugger White Johnny Bratton (x3) Dave Castilloux Sonny West Ronnie James Lester Felton Willie Roache Lulu Constantino Joe Miceli Bobby Ruffin Bill Speary Buddy Garcia Gene Burton (x2) Ralph Zannelli (x2) Jesse Flores Joey Peralta Willie Joyce Freddie Dawson (x3) Maxie Berger Juan Zurita Tony Pellone Rudy Cruz (x2) Nick Moran Enrique Bolanos (x3) Williams also beat these Hall of Famers: Sammy Angott (x2) Bob Montgomery Kid Gavilan Beau Jack (x2) That's forty two wins against 'name' opponents. This is why Williams is an all-time great.
[YT]eseoeLTHnWk[/YT] Highlights of rounds ten to fifteen of Williams-Bolanos II. The 'worst' performance by Williams of their trilogy, although still a comfortable points win that should have been labelled unanimous rather than a split decision. In this portion of the fight, Williams is showing disdain for Bolanos' punches which consist mostly of flurried jabs. He fights with a lower guard than in previous rounds, stalking Bolanos and baiting himself, waiting for the right opportunity. It's more of a Carlos Ortiz approach to things, this one - think Ortiz-Bizzarro, except more in favour of Ike. Williams lands his own jabs, but every now and then he lands a series of hard shots which Bolanos escapes from but is affected by both points-wise and physically. Two good examples of this: 0:45 - 0:55 2:10 - 2:18