he won by a round on 2 cards. some were hard to score, good fight with good scores, but it was very close fight, cotto wasn't a "clear winner" by any means.
where did i say it was controversial? cottos fans are acting like it was a walk in the park. tell me this if you had bet your house on the outcome would you have been nervous before the cards were read? if it was so CLEAR the answer would be no, in this case i think anyone in that position would be shitting bricks. i never even said i thought shane won. but it was a very very close fight and could have gone either way.