No he hasn't, same fighter, different situations. He has the potential to be greater than Calzaghe, but he'll need to live up to his hype and be special. Clear out 168 if you can, then dominate at 175, then it's a serious debate.
Cokezaghe didnt dominate 175. He picked 2 old guys to beat. And the one old guy he beat he looked horrible doing so. If Ward beats Bute and Froch, that'll give him 3 fighters on his resume that are better then 99% of Slappy Joes wins. Dominating and establishing himself as the best super middleweight in an era that is clearly stronger then Coke Slaps era will clearly propel him ahead.
calzaghe was old too they were his last fights, hopkins is still kicking arse today 3 years later or whatever it is. speed fighters always deteriorate earlier than other fighters as its the first thing to go.
Wards 18 month era as a supreme SMW is stronger than Calzaghe's 10 year period? If he beats Bute and Froch he'll have three wins that are better than Joes? are you talking about the mighty Allan Green, or Arthur Turtle Shell Abraham? You're right though, Calzaghe never dominated 175, I will say that one of the two 'old guys' he beat was the lineal champion.
JC would have dominated any of the SMW of today.shame he wasnt around in the Eubank,Benn,Collins golden era as he would of dominated then 2
Yes or do you think the likes of Tocker Pudwill, Mario Viet and Richie Woodhall were great victories? Please tell me, before Jeff Lacy, who did Calzaghe beat that matters? If he beats Bute and Froch he'll have three wins that are better than Joes? are you talking about the mighty Allan Green, or Arthur Turtle Shell Abraham?[/quote] Im talking about Kessler. Who Ward beat more decisively. A lineal champion that was also 43 years old.
Shot out, old, soon to be retired Eubanks and then he takes ten years off. You are way overrating Eubanks anyway.
He wasn't even defending a legitimate title. His title was plucked from the trash and no one considered the wbo a legit sanctioning body at the time. They were no better than the wbu back then, not much better now.
you seem to be forgetting british fighters arnt allowed these american belts, look at you americant's crying now because the klits own the belts, all of a sudden the hw division is a waste of time, just as the smw was a waste of time and cruiser weight division was a waste of time...until an american comes along.