In what order do u have Holyfield, Lewis, and Tyson on ur ATG list?

Lewis, Tyson, Holyfield for me.

It's close between Tyson and Holy, but i think Tyson just shades it. Lewis definitely best of the three IMO.

 

At heavyweight Lewis, Holyfield then Tyson.

 

Lewis.
Holyfield.
Tyson.





Eric Crumble.

 

same as mcgrain.

i have it

lewis
tyson
holyfield.

 

Holyfield's achivements at Cruiser & Heavy put him slightly ahead of Lewis overall. Although I consider Lewis a better Heavy.

 

Holyfield, Lewis, Tyson

 

Lewis
Holy
Danny Wiliams
Tyson

 

Heavy:

Lewis
Holy
Tyson

Overall

Holy
Lewis
Tyson


I've always thought that. But am starting to think perhaps I'm giving too much weight to Holy beating Tyson, and not enough to Tyson being the youngest Heavy champ.

I'm judging on career from start to finish.
Depends on how you judge it. I could understand somebody having the complete opposite.

 

ATG:

Lewis
Holy
Tyson

prime-H2H:

Tyson
Lewis
Holy

 

holyfield should be marked down IMO because of the use of HGH as a heavy.

this is cheating and holyfield i am pretty sure reading the evidence used this a lot on his move up from heavy.

he used it so much it gave him the enlarged heart , which killed flo jo albeit doctors caught it in time with holyfield, albeit they layed the blame on his prolonged HGH use.

lewis and tyson were clean as far as we can tell of performing enhancing drugs.

one of the side effects of HGH is increased eye brow bone and you only have to look at holyfield the cruiser to holyfield now to see he has considerably altered facially in this regard

This content is protected

 

Tyson - The youngest champ ever, and last unquestionably dominant and feared HW, before Wlad

Holy - Multiple championships, great opposition...not to mention Lifetime Achievement Award

Lennox - Unified champ, beat all his previous opposition, but not feared or a four time world champ

 

Lewis
Tyson
Holyfield

 

Same here.