In what order do u have Holyfield, Lewis, and Tyson on ur ATG list?

Riddick Bowe gave up his belt rather than face Lewis. Holyfield and Tyson didn't want anything to do with him for years. You're also incorrect on the second point. Lewis won the WBC belt on 3 occasions, and the IBF and WBA belts as well as the Undisputed Championship.

 

Lewis

Holyfield

Tyson

 

Still gotta go with Tyson here. Yes, he damaged his legacy by fighting well past his prime, but he was a far more dominant champ than either of the afforementioned. He defended his title 10 time and he was truly feared. Level of competition. Well, between the three I'd have to say the Michael Spinks was probably the best fighter than either of them beat...maybe Bowe.

 

Holyfield
Lewis
Tyson
bottom two are close

Prime H2H

Tyson


Holyfield







Lewis

 

Lewis
Holyfield
Tyson

But it's close, you could argue that head to head Tyson would have beaten the other 2. Or you could say that Holyfield's cruiserweight achievements elevate him above the others.

 

Lennox

Evander

Mike

otherwise it was just copy/paste.

And beïng a 4 time champion doesn't say much if you are in the WBA cycle, where every 'sort of contender' with ties with Don King has the chance to be 'The WBA Heavyweight Champion of the World and Beyond'.

 

1. Lennox Lewis
2.
3.
4A. Evander Holyfield
4B. Mike Tyson

 

Legacy wise

lewis
holyfield
tyson

prime h2h

lewis beats holyfield

holyfield stops tyson

half the time tyson kayos lewis, other half lewis ud's him

 

The Tyson that stopped Spinks would have steamrolled Evander. I love him and he's one of my favorite of all time, but there's no way he would have been able to compete with a focused Tyson. Evander didn't have a single advantage other than height. Tyson was faster, stronger, hit harder and had better defense.

 

Lewis
Holyfield
Tyson

 

Also, younger Tyson would have crippled young Lewis. At the time, Lewis was a completely incomplete fighter. He had a big right hand and nothing else. Watch the Tucker and Bruno fights. He used his left as a rang finder. Tyson would have demolished him.

 

Holyfield
Lewis
Tyson
However, when it comes to impact and legendary status...TYSON!
He ranks up there with Ali if not equally.

 

I think if your british or from the us your vote shouldnt count for obvious reasons the brits will always pick lewis and the yanks will be split with holy and tyson. I am not british or from the usa so my vote means more.
H2H 1. Tyson
2. Holyfield
3. Lewis
Any body else who isnt british or from the usa?

 

HW ATG

Lewis
Holyfield
Tyson

Prime H2H
Lewis/Tyson
Holyfield

ATG
Holyfield
Lewis
Tyson

 

Lewis
Holyfield
Tyson

Prime H2H

Lewis UD Holyfield
Tyson UD Holyfield
Tyson KO Lewis