Is Archie Moore in your TOP 10 P4P(ALL TIME) ?

Yeah, I wasn't recanting on that, undoubtedly Charles>Moore. But my original logic was unfair with this "interesting situation." I think you understood, I wanted to clarify just in case.

Also, even though you agree, for people who don't: Let's say Vitali after the Byrd loss would have came back and swept HW for a decade instead of his brother, getting all the wins he could have at the time: Would anyone rate Vitali>Lennox? What if Lennox had gone to another division and made 9 defenses, including beating the arguable GOAT and most achieved in that division's history?

 

Sorry Rummy. Meant I would have put him up there had he beat 1, 2 or all of those.
At LHW I can for sure , but not p4p

 

Just outside of the top 10 for me

 

I don't have a list, but the result of Rummy' vid sounds about right to me - #13.

 

What's Manny doing there? is he going to wait tables at dinner?

 

LOL people get so wrapped up in this crap but the truth is there's no such thing

 

I think it's very reasonable to put Moore inside the top 10. Now personally for some reason, I keep forgetting about how great he actually was. I think anything from 8 or 9 to 15 seems pretty good to me. Very interesting though, since I feel like Moore is one of the more underappreciated guys.
I would commit a murder to watch the Charles v Moore fights.

 

I feel like the fact that we don't have any of the fights is so tragic. It makes me sad, whenever I think about it. If I could add another I would add Greb vs Tunney, to finally see how Greb actually fought. Hell, If I'm at it give me Robinson at WW as well.

 

No. At a push, he could maybe be considered in the top 20 but I’d rank him between 21-24

 

My top ten:
1. Ali
2. Robinson
3, Duran
4. Chavez
5. Armstrong
6. Moore
7. Pep
8. Louis
9. Monzon
10. Greb

1-5 are solid choices, 6 to 10 change every day.