Is beating JMM at 130lbs or 145lbs the same?!

No, it's not. IMO, JMM doesn't really belong in the WW div.

 

We wont know until after Mayweather or JMMs next fights.

Mayweather could well have just came back an improved
fighter over the break - and might be too slick for not only
JMM, but everyone.

Or, JMM could continue to fail as a Welter, Mayweather
could get beaten - and then we will know if JMM is as
good at 145 as he was at 130.

Most posters will already say NO, just to discredit Mayweather,
which seems to be the theme around here, it was a ***** move
by Floyd to come in over the weight, but has nothing to do with
JMMs ability to fight at 145.

 

JMM was ATG at Feather and Superfeather...
JMM was (might still be) very good/ almost great at LW...
JMM was slow, sort of fat, his age beginning to show and somewhat average at Welterweight. I even think JWW is too high for JMM

 

No it isn't. Conversely, I give Mayweather more credit for his win over De la Hoya than I do Pacquiao. The Marquez that Mayweather faught was older and waaay out of his comfort zone than the Marquez that Pacquiao fought.

 

Above Deck, I could tell that this thread was made to just discredit May's win but I can't help thinking that Marquez looked like a shell of himself (even though May does have something to do with that...I don't think it was Floyd who made him appear completely average, fat and slow as if he was there to cash a check) he needs to get down to 135 where I think he and Funeka might make for a good ****ing scrap.

 

tell the PBF fans, that's fine. I'm retty sure the boxing fans know what's up. WAs a good one for Floyd. I think a more interesting question is who you all go Hoya who fought Pac vs. marquez who fought May

 

At 145 lb, that was the worst version of JMM that I have seen, too slow, too tentative and apparently lacked power in his punches. Probably, the extra lbs was too much for his legs and body to carry.

 

excellent question my friend. its obvious. where was his mgmt or advisors when the dec was made?? 15 lbs???? thats a whole lot of weight!! did he really think he could move up that much and beat floyd?? at least with manny, it was a little bit at a time and GRADUALLY! jmm tried to do it all in 1 fight against, arguably, the best p4p today. maybe it was the money.

 

Obviously not, JMM is a slow, fat, plodder at 145.

 

Even 140 is too high for him, I have a funny feeling Hatton will stop him

 

When the **** are you gonna get over it ****? Move onto something else, make a priority in your life something other than hating Mayweather. You will feel better for it. This topic has been thrashed.

Someone close thread.

 

He's not the same athlete at 145.

 

hell... JMM would probably still be at 130 if he wasn't chasing Pac