Is Evander Holyfield the greatest warrior the sport has ever seen?

Or what ? You're going to strike me with lightning from you avatar ?

He is a close friend of Gerry Cooney and has rubbed shoulders with Hollyfield
....tells me that he is a jerk....didn't go into details and I wasn't interested enough to enquire....however, you peaked my curiosity and I will ask him.

 

Defintely, and if my avatar had a big pair of tits I'd slap you with them:good. That being said, I was curious as well when you mentioned-Holyfield always "seemed" to be one of the good guys in this sport.

 

really good points, and i forgot about his health condition (heart)

 

This content is protected

 

Absolutely not. He has some good wins but great warriors at HW do not get flattened by body shots from a fat former middleweight, no matter how old they are.

Lets not forget that Ruiz also floored him :shock: and Moorer out-pointed him....Holy is way too inconsistent to be given that kind of plaudit. Give it to Hagler instead, I'd understand that.

 

Can't be said if he is or isn't, but there's no question he's a contender. Same as.

 

Chavez is the greatest warrior ever

 

Yeah, that's why he quit during the second Randall fight right? :yep

What do his losses when he's old have to do with him not being a warrior? Doesn't change the fact that he fought everyone and anyone, both in his era, and future eras. Please man, you gonna degrade Gatti for getting knocked out by a guy with just 13 ko's? Or Vargas by getting Ko'd by former lightweights? They were old and past it, and winning and losing has nothing to do with wether or not they're warriors or not. Their past history proves that they are.

 

Something like this is impossible to tell. Having an iron chin or overall durable body can make you look like a warrior. Head/bodies take punishment in different ways. A guy like Hagler, yeah he's a warrior, he has an iron chin, but if you get hit hard enough your legs will go and it doesn't matter how much heart you have, you won't be getting up. That's why I never judge quitters or anything, no one knows how much pain they were suffering or how hurt they really were except them.

Corrales got hit and hurt, sure, but he was still physically able to get up. In the second Castillo fight, no matter how much heart he had, he was flattened. A guy like Khan, he has a "glass jaw", he got up from that huge KD, he has really hurt and wobbly, he was done, but tons of people make fun of him and would never list him as a "warrior", that's crap to me.

 

Not all-time, but in the past 20-30 years probably yes

 

He'd certainly make a top 10 list over the last 25 years, but greatest ever I'm afraid not. Many people have listed fighters they thought were great warriors but so far no one's mentioned Duran, who I consider the greatest warrior I've ever had the pleasure of watching.

 

I'd say a guy like Gatti is. Just because he didn't have the talent a guy like Holyfield had. He needed to gut out some of his wins and take beat downs because he wasn't an ATG like Holy. But Holyfield was definitely a warrior.