Is felix trinidad top 75 atg

Hell no, this is not a popularity contest, voting or acknowleging that someone is an atg (in this case top75).

Just look back into the days of the old timers - there alone you should find enough fighters who are rather a top75 atg than tito...

 

#64 Imo.

 

He isn't an all time great.....he lost to nearly all the big timers he fought......ATG doesnt mean decent fighter not from Europe that had some big fights....Mayweather, De La Hoya, Roy Jones, Hopkins, Whittaker are ATG but no way can Tito be considered a great

 

Tito's a HOF, but not an ATG in my opinion. Real elite ATG's simply don't lose as badly as he did when he was still fresh.

DLH for example, has much more claim than Tito, never being dominated despite losing some.

 

DLH, Mayweather jr and RJJ are 100% certainties to be known as all time greats....Mayweather needed the win over oscar to seal that but oscar was already and ATG by then and even when he loses again later this year he was still the golden boy of a generation...tito lost way too many fights

 

So you're saying that no one can be an ATG if they get dominated in their prime right?

 

DLH is far from a certainty as an ATG, but Mayweather is a certainty and RJJ is cemented.

 

so if oscar squeezes a decision out of the mayweather fight is he an ATG??

 

Not at all, but Tito is particularly limited, was dominated BADLY twice when he was not at his best weight of course, but was still at a good age.

Both of the types that dominated him were defensive counter punchers, obviously he can't deal with that style, but he couldn't deal with DLH for a number of rounds either.

He's got an 'okay' resume, but overall, he's really not that impressive despite being exciting and most real top 75 ATG's, were always at least in a fight, not shutout and made to look like an amatuer twice.

 

Getting totally dominated twice is far worse than losing 4 very competitive fights.:yep

 

who ranks higher for you then buddy in all time listings...oscar or tito?? just your opinion im after not facts and stats