Dlh, Tito, and Floyd are hof, but no way ATG's. big difference. To be an ATG you need to be the dominant fighter of your time or simply the best. Even if that fighter lost, but avenged his losses in convincing fashion they are ATG's. Also, it's how the people remember the fighters accomplishments and performances. Of the 3, Floyd has the better chance of being one in the future if he returned with a victory over a Margo, PW, or Cotto, who are all in their primes. The only noteworthy fighters on Floyd's resume are an old DLH, Jose Luis Castillo who some thought won the first fight, and Chico Corrales, all hofs. And there ain't no shame in that.