Is Floyd Mayweather the GREATEST WELTERWEIGHT OF ALL TIME?

Pbf is the best fighter of his era. He's an elite atg

 

The sun shines out of his backside too right Pimp ? lol

 

Not in my book I'm afraid. Pac was the fighter of the era

 

ROFLMAO You'd never get Floyd within 100 miles of a boxing ring if Tommy Hearns was in it. The way he freaked out when he saw Antonio Margarito standing in front of him Floyd would have a litter of kittens if he saw Tommy

 

I am a Mayweather fan I like his fighting style but this bloke is a next level ass licker. How can anyone confirm somebody winning a fantasy fight with fighters from another era lol

 

I said others. There seems to be different for criterias for Floyd than others from yesteryear.

 

Hearns would put margo in a coma

 

Who the heck is Margarito?

 

Not sure why you quoted me then.

 

Maybe but Maybe Tony would nail him first. One thing I'm certain of Pimp & that is Tony wouldn't duck a fight with Tommy & run away embarrassed like Floyd did when he saw Tony standing there ROFL did a fantastic job of imitating Daffy Duck lol

 

Floyd's Master that's who Margarito is LOL Ive never seen a man look so terrified as Floyd did when he saw Tony ROFL How embarrassing the one that calls himself TBE losing control like that he was hysterical

 

That has nothing to do with what I just said. I believe that Floyd is an atg. I have never stated otherwise in this thread. You mentioned that Floyd was the greatest at 130 because of his resume and dominance. I then brought up Alexis who had a better resume and more dominance at 130. You switched the topic to talking about h2h match ups. Now you're just stating that Floyd is great. Something that I never refuted. My point was that you mentioned two reasons why Floyd was the greatest at 130 but Alexis fits those reasons better. Either you have other criteria that you haven't mentioned or you forgot about Arguello. Under the criteria that you gave me there is no reason why Floyd is greater than Alexis at 130.

 

Tell ya what Pimp If Floyd had the stones to fight Margarito, as the fans wanted, & legitimately beat him I'd respect him. If he fought him & Tony beat the hell out of him I'd still respect him. The fact he ducked like a coward theres no way in hades I'd respect Floyd

 

Agree with this. Arguello has the better resume.
In a H2H would I favor Floyd? Yes but there is no guarantee as both are great fighters and either could win.

 

Still never heard of him so he couldn't have been any good