I don't think that its a matter of opinion, no matter what boxer it is ... no matter if you're new to boxing or not. I think that no one opinion trumps another ... and it isn't right for someone to say that someone's opinion isn't valid and try to make a point to dispute it. So what if I think Floyd is the greatest ever ... thats my opinion and no one on these boards can change that.
Exactly, where are all the Hall of Famers and all-time greats? We can name many fighters he clearly ducked. The resume is thinner than most think and the career's of the people he fought have been dismal after he fought them-cherry picking at it's best.