Is Hatton still amongst the top 10 P4P?

I have him at number 10. Sure Malignaggi didn't live up to expectations but that's his failing and no fault of Hatton's. He was the number 2 fighter at 140 and Hatton beat him dominantly.

 

Yes, number ten.

 

His critics were too harsh when he lost but I think he has to partially blame himself for that. He built it all up to the Floyd/P4P fight so that when he lost, everyone thought that was the end.

 

as of right now, i officially dont care about p4p lists outside of the top 5.....anyone outside of that can change with there next fight

top 5
1.Pacman
2.JMM
3.Calz
4.Bhop
5.Vasquez

thats should be everybodies top 5, not necessarily the order, because some people believe Calzaghe should be #2...and thats fair and i dont know maybe some people beleive JMM should be #1...who knows, but those people should be in everyones top 5 even if the order is different

but to answer the question, yeah i'd say Hatton could fall anywhere between 6-10

 

top 5

 

No

 

:rofl

Damn dude, you should really go watch UFC or some ****, top 5

Beating Paulie Malignaggi who was nowhere near the P4P lists gets you from outside the top 10 to top 5 on your list?

 

Definately

 

i have him 11/12 and im a huge hatton fan. a win over de la hoya/pac/jmm would solidify his status in top 10 in my mind.

 

top5 is a bit much but he did dominate his closest rival at 140 to reiterate he is still the best 140 pounder in the world.

 

1 Pacquiao
2 Calzaghe
3 Hopkins
4 Marquez
5 Vazquez
6 Margarito
7 Calderon
8 Williams
9 Marquez
10 Darchinyan

 

I've changed my mind no.Malignaggi wasn't top 50 pound for pound when Hatton beat him.

 

Although he proved me wrong in the Paulie fight he is not in my top 10. Between 10-15 would be fair imo.

 

People kept Cotto in when he lost to Margarito ffs, who wasn't even in top 25. Hatton loses to p4p number 1 and boom gone forever. He's top ten for me.

 

I dont see anywhere near 10 guys who dominate their respective divisions like Hatton has done.I believe him when he says he wont be beaten at 140.