Is Haye now worthy of a P4P rating?

Top 10 is pushing it, could get in the top 15 though IMO.

The Ring's rankings are terrible

 

i voted no because you didnt dictate how low the list would go therfore i went for would he replace any of the current top 10

top 25 maybe top 40 for sure

 

nooooooooooo

 

The ring overrates north american fighters hugely. To not see even one european fighter there where Paul Williams gets a place after a razor thin win.

Guys like Marquez and Hopkins are more in their position due to reputation as opposed to recent performances.

 

I actually have Williams 4th in my list. Donaire, Cotto, Cab and Hopkins are the fighters that I think they are overrating.

 

I'd have him in that list instead of Dawson.

 

He be in and around the top 10-12 P4P. P4P should be for guys who are frequently fighting the best in and around there weight divisions or at least fighting as there's a few in that list who only fight once a year if that.

The Ring makes some strange choices but Haye's not far of P4P Top 10 imo.

 

Looking at that list you have to say yes...

 

If you put Haye in there, you have to have the Klits in there too.

I really like Haye, but you can't rate him above either of the K brothers until he beats one.

 

No.

But that ring list is one of the worst ive seen.

I dont think Haye can be included if Wlad isnt there.

 

who the **** voted yes on this?








... but then again, nonito donaire is in there so maybe he is worthy of that piece of **** list!

 

In my list, no.

If we are taking the ring list from above, probably yes.

That's awful.

 

Not unless Wlad is too.

But why Hopkins and Cotto are on that list I don't know, you may as well keep Hatton on there if Cotto stays.