Is It Fair To Label Lucian Bute The #1 SMW?

And Ward never won against Bika or Andrade. :good

The question is not to determine if Bute is the number one but to find if it's fair. i don't find it unfair to put Bute at number one because Ward has only one big win (Kessler's next couple of fights will tell us what he is really worth) and Abraham is new to the division. So, it's not unfair to put Bute number 1. It's not unfair to put Abraham or Ward (I would prefer Ward) but it is to pu Froch, who didn't look good in his two last fights.

 

The question is...have you ever see any of the SMW fighters (even Calzaghe) knock down a guy like Bute is able to do...the anwser is no...Bute is the 1 SMW.

 

Yes

 

Andrade would lose to Dirrel, and Ward. Kessler already easily beat Andrade.

 

Indeed but they have not for the moment.

 

Everyone in the tournament would lose to Bute

 

How do you know that? Can you see the future!!?? :yikes

 

Wasn't taliking to you.
BTW thats a great prediction

 

He shoulda joined the tourney then, than take on that one demontional plod andrade.

 

I'm sorry Gneus, please forgive my rudeness. It's a brave statement saying Bute would beat everyone in the SuperSix, when his biggest win is Andrade, who Kessler dominated fairly easy. We can all see his skills, but in order to know who he'd beat, he needs to face them. You can't just say he beats them all.

 

He wasn't invited.

 

Did he have the option?

 

No, I'd say Froch is right now.

 

You do know he wasnt invited right?

And if he didn't fight Andrade again everybody would say he's ducking and stuff and blame him for not fight Andrade.

 

Ok well i woulda given him more respect for beating Jermaine Taylor than Andrade even now.