I saw the fights between Hatton v. Pacquiao and Hopkins v. Pavlik recently, with both Hatton and Pavlik losing in devastating fashion, albeit in different ways. In both fights there was talk that the fighters that lost should change up their styles because what they had previously done is no longer working. However, since both fighters, especially Hatton, are very much developed into their styles, the question is whether an experience fighter can change up how they fight with the help of a new trainer? What do you guys think? http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=97509
Gatti and Barrera come to mind. Hopkins also looks nothing now like he did in the mid 90s. It takes time, effort, talent, and an actual willingness to change.
Yes, of course it's possible. I've seen quite a few examples of it; Barrera, Julio "The Cuban Lover" Garcia went from boxer-puncher to brawler for a more crowd pleasing style, Winky Wright was a cutie early in his career and then became a high guard aggressor, Floyd Sr. turned Bojado from a seek and destroy attacker to a pure boxer for the Rubio rematch, and I think Quintana also used to be more aggressive earlier in his career and of course now he's a smooth slickster. You can do it but the fighter needs smarts, willingness, and consistent dedication. It also depends on the boxer's naturaly physical ability because you're not going to turn guys like Marciano and Joe Frazier into lateral moving boxers.
Its extremely difficult, I think when we saw Gatti and Barrera change their style they always had the ability in their repotiore anyway, it just took for example Buddy McGirt to bring it out of him, I doubt Buddy taught him anything he didnt already know...
Gatti was a boxer earlier in his career he just happened to brawl more for a few years there and all that McGirt did was bring him back to his old style.
Hatton didn't need to change his style, he just needed to do the basics right. Keep his hands up, move his head. Still be a pressure fighter, but a better one. He didn't do that.
Styles are hardwired into ones brain. If one practices a certain way for 15 years, the circuits in their brain will not be meant for a dramatically different style.
The best example is Ali. The early 60s fighter is pretty much unrecognizable from the mid 70s version, yet both were at the top of the game.