Is Jack Dempsey the most overrated fighter of all time

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by SuzieQ49, Jul 16, 2015.


  1. Entaowed

    Entaowed Boxing Addict banned Full Member

    6,837
    4,174
    Dec 16, 2012
    Wilt said 20,000 woman & it was nothing like that.

    Almost all "notice", & it is highly relevant to understand cultures & improve deeply racist biases by individuals, governments & folks in power.
    Being blind to these issues is not useful to fixing things.

    Dempsey was a man of his time re: racism.
    But he may have treated individual blacks well.
    And he did follow the guidance of management re:who to fight when.
     
  2. billy smith

    billy smith Member Full Member

    273
    11
    Jul 17, 2015
    So you think if Ricard would have chosen Wills instead of Firpo Dempsey would have declined
    the 6 hundred thousand payday ?
     
  3. billy smith

    billy smith Member Full Member

    273
    11
    Jul 17, 2015
    Dempsey and Kearns didn't choose to fight Gibbons over Wills..The townspeople of Shelby offered a 100 grand to fight whoever they chose..And Gibbons was willing to do it for free..
    They didn't choose Carpentier over Wills ..Rickard offered 300 grand to fight Carpentier they said yes...You offer Kearns a few 100 grand he will have Dempsey fight anyone..
    Regardless of what Muldoon might say in public his racism was bone deep and everything he did..Was done intentionally to derail it..The reason he demanded a NY fight could only take place with a cap on ticket prices..Was to ensure it would never take place ..All Kearns cared about was money..The one time
    someone made a attempt to make it happen Dempsey signed on the dotted line..
     
  4. mr. magoo

    mr. magoo VIP Member Full Member

    51,139
    25,327
    Jan 3, 2007
    I was glad to post it. Great quote and so very true. And yes, I do concur that sometimes revisionism can be used for marketing purposes as well.
     
  5. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    400
    Jan 22, 2010
    And Mc, Dempsey dropped big George Godfrey several times in their sparring sessions. He also manhandled Big Bill Tate who was his sparring partner...Dempsey absolutely FEASTED on much larger men, as he combined MW speed and heavyweight power, lest we forget...
     
  6. mcvey

    mcvey VIP Member Full Member

    97,745
    29,119
    Jun 2, 2006
    1916-07-14
    181 John Lester Johnson 170 12 3 0








    Harlem S.C., New York, New York, USA D NWS 10/10
    This content is protected

    This content is protected








    This content is protected

    This content is protected






    D
    NWS
    10/10



    Harlem S.C., New York, New York, USA
    referee: Billy 'Kid' McPartland
    Newspaper decision from New York City newspapers (Jack Kincaid).
    Opinions as to the winner were divided. For instance, one report said that "Dempsey failed to live up to the reputation that he earned in Salt Lake city, and was an easy mark for the local boxer." But another said "Neither boxer was ever in danger, but at the finish Johnson was very tired from the heavy punishment he received in the mid-section and around the head." The weights mentioned varied from one newpaper to another, but the ones listed look most probable Doesn't seem to be the beatdown some claim?
     
  7. billy smith

    billy smith Member Full Member

    273
    11
    Jul 17, 2015
    Also one thing I feel that Dempsey excelled at perhaps more then anyone else
    was the Slug Out..When both fighters mostly ignore defense but just try to knock each others brains out..The point in a boxing match where it becomes a fight..
    The fight is where he was at his most dangerous ..
     
  8. SuzieQ49

    SuzieQ49 The Manager Full Member

    37,077
    3,733
    Sep 14, 2005
    Wills Dempsey 50-50. Wills was very strong and tough on the inside, good enough to clinch Dempsey when he got inside, and he had a powerful uppercut. Dempsey never fought a big man with the skills and power of wills

    Dempsey Greb 60-40 for Dempsey. Greb did far better against common opponents.
     
  9. SuzieQ49

    SuzieQ49 The Manager Full Member

    37,077
    3,733
    Sep 14, 2005
    Then why did he nearly lose a slug out to Luis firpo? Firpo was not a good fighter
     
  10. SuzieQ49

    SuzieQ49 The Manager Full Member

    37,077
    3,733
    Sep 14, 2005
    There are several articles of Godfrey dropping Dempsey and hurting him in sparring. Funny Dempsey nor Tunnry never gave the hall of fame Godfrey a title shot
     
  11. janitor

    janitor VIP Member Full Member

    71,585
    27,251
    Feb 15, 2006
    Why should they have?
     
  12. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    400
    Jan 22, 2010
    B.S.---Dempsey in a regular fight would have been a prohibitive favorite to ko the ponderous George Godfrey...He had floored big George in several sparring sessions....You in your blind hatred for Jack Dempsey know squat about him and his times...Do YOU SIR know more about his ERA than the thousands of boxing writers, famous fighters of his times, trainers who saw him fight ringside, and watched him sparring with his Sparring partners time and again ???... In your heart of hearts you KNOW the answer, but
    your agenda knows no limits...Have a good day, and by the way
    Jack Dempsey at his rip roaring best was a helluva PURE fist fighter...:hi:
     
  13. billy smith

    billy smith Member Full Member

    273
    11
    Jul 17, 2015
    At what point did he nearly lose..he made it back in the ring inside of ten..
    The ropes were lose he probably wouldn't have went out..Some fighters are at a disadvantage slugging it out
    If its not their strength they don't want to get caught in a slugging match..Some fighters need to try to get their opponent in a slugging match..Firpo initially told Ricard he wasn't ready for Dempsey and wanted to wait a year to fight anyone for the title..But Ricard told him he may not get a lot of money next year if he waits . But he will this year if he fights..
    The promoters of that era didn't care if someone was entitled to a title shot.
    They only care if the gate will draw..Ricard before he promoted the Jeffries Johnson fight had no problem promoting mixed matches..He would play-up the racial differences just to sell more seats..
    But after the 1910 race riots the heat he got for it. He swore he would never
    promote a fight between a white man and a black man again..Far as i know he didn't..Unfortunately no one with the money who could have made a Will Dempsey fight happen was interested in making it happen..
    Johnson would never got a title shot if Burns stayed in America cause no on would promote it..Only Johnson had the brains to realize he needed to take matters in his own hands ,if he wanted a title shot..To follow Burns to other countries..hounding him..
    None of the other Black fighters of his day had Johnsons ability as a self=made man to figure this out..Then they wanted Johnson after he had the brains and the drive accomplish the impossible task of a black man fighting for the championship..To give them a title shot
    If Wills like Langford,Jeanette,McVey before him. Would have had Johnson's
    ability as a self made man and the brains to make it happen .Instead of waiting
    for a someone to make it happen for him..
    He'd had a better chance of getting a title shot .But he just waited around expecting someone to make a Dempsey Wills fight happen. Instead of creating the conditions that people would fight over .Just to be the one to make a Dempsey Wills fight happen.
    Where were the black promoters back then
    why didn't they promote it?
    (You should look into that and ask their descendants
    why they never got a Wills Dempsey fight going )

    To answer your statement that Dempsey almost lost to Firpo ..Dempsey took some hard shots his only question after the first round was "What round is this"
    By the second round Jack was firmly in control..
     
  14. SuzieQ49

    SuzieQ49 The Manager Full Member

    37,077
    3,733
    Sep 14, 2005

    Wills went 4-1-1 with 2 knockouts against Big Bill Tate. His only loss came on a DQ when he hit Tate while he was on the floor from a knockdown in the first round.

    Wills was 36 years old when he fought Sharkey. Dempsey had been retired for 4 years when he was 36. Dempsey beat Sharkey, after losing almost every round and having revert to going low.

    More like he built his standing by beating hall of fame top rated contenders whom willard and dempsey wouldn't fight like Sam Langford(Dempsey ducked him in 1917), Joe Jeanette(Dempsey ran out of the ring against him in 1918) and Sam McVea.

    Langford, McVea, Jeanette alone are better than Dempsey's best victims.

    Except when those 2 contenders are so much better than everyone else. No one was a close 3rd.
     
  15. SuzieQ49

    SuzieQ49 The Manager Full Member

    37,077
    3,733
    Sep 14, 2005
    "Godfrey was the best of them all. I've sparred with Dempsey and fought just about every good heavyweight out there and I will tell you, George Godfrey was the best. I was afraid of only two men in my life, My Father and George Godfrey."- Larry Gains




    EASTERN SNAPSHOTS by W. Rollo Wilson



    Nov.12, 1925-The Baron of Leiperville is home again with wonderous tales of the mighty deeds of the "Shadow" along the gilded slope. The "Shadow" is just another way of denoting Gorger George Godfrey, Jimmy's (Dougherty) outsize white elephant. For white elephant George seems now to be. Nobody wants to fight him for love or money. Mr. Wills unostentatiously draws the color line. Mr. Tunney is more blatant in his announcement to the same effect. "I'll fight Harry Wills," broadcasts James Joseph, "but I draw the color line on George Godfrey."



    Two things may be on the mind of the Apollo of Greenwich Village, Perhaps he thinks that one "shot" with Wills would give him enough of the filthy lucre for his future earthly needs. Win or lose he would be "in." Fighting Ole Black Lightning [Godfrey] would be a case of all to lose and nothing to gain, he probably thinks. At this time Billy Gibson and Tunney are saying that the Big Three of Boxing are Dempsey, Wills, and the modest Gene. Godfrey would fain make it a foursome, but you can be jolly well sure that the triumvira will continue to say him nay.



    One of the first acts of [Dougherty] on his arrival was to release another challenge in the general direction of the above-mentioned Big Three. His latest offer is this:

    All any promoter has to do is get Harry, Gene or Jack to sign the papers and pay them whatever they want. Godfrey will come in without asking for a dollar. The aftermath will provide the Dougherty clan with all they will want, because they feel that George can take any of the three.



    As is well known Dougherty and Dempsey are the best of friends. Last summer a year ago (1924) Dempsey visited the baronial halls (Leiperville). While here the subject of a bout with George was broached. Jack declared that if he fought at all he would fight Wills,
    This content is protected
    Jimmy pressed him for the reason and he said :
    This content is protected
    , Wills is getting older and I think he will be the easier man of the two. That is the reason I prefer to fight him, if I fight."
    - ROLLO WILSON was often referred to as "The dean of the Black Press.