Is James Toney an ATG?

Didn't Hopkins lose to Jermaine Taylor :think

Ped's don't make you a defensive genius ,Hopkins most notable fights were against smaller fighters ..Toney's wins over better caliber fighters also adds to his argument all time it also proves how he would perform against the best ..What's Hopkins' defining Fight really ?

 

he was referring to this part of the quote i believe

Saying Toney's punch was a fluke.

 

Me too :good

 

how is he an oscar fan? hes far from it.

 

He is a ATG nuff said .

 

How can a fighter who has been found to have something in their system that they shouldnt, be an ATG?

Is it forgotten how many Split Dec's Toney had?
How many felt he looked fortunate against Tiberi?
How Toney lost to Thadzi?
How Toney lost to novice M Griffin?
How Toney at first ask couldnt beat S Williams?
How poor Toneys competition as SMW champ was?
How Toney couldnt compete at LHW?

I am not qualified to make a decision as to whether someone is an ATG or not, but I dont think Toney is

 

Who was this top CW that Toney beat? Do you mean Jirov? What were Jirovs 5 best wins?

 

More boxing rec crap ,do you even know who Montell Griffen's trainer was for the Toney fight ? I doubt that's highlighted on boxing rec ..And correction your not qualified to talk about boxing but yet you do

 

Probably is, despite being a fat joke

 

[yt]P9SbWrZEvc0[/yt]

 

1:35 of the video above. Very hard to hit James with a solid punch

 

Griffins trainer wasnt in the ring with Toney, so stop waffling.
Whats Boxrec in saying Toney looked lucky to many against Tiberi?
You seem to wear rose tinted glasses and be in denial with alot of your posts. This is why you get schooled so often. Remove the glasses and look at the whole career

 

Either way most pundits and writers had it a very tight fight.

 

yeah with oscar winning tho