Is Joe Calzaghe a top 100 atg

He is 102 on my list

 

Of course he is.

 

Its debatable but i would probably say no.

 

in the end only the top 25 count everythign else is interchangable. so if he isn't in the top 25 does it really matter.

 

I can picture him whooping the asses of many other ATG's, soooo....yes. But I'm speaking in a strictly p4p ATG sense. If we're talking resumes, there are probably 100 guys out there with better ones.

 

His only 2 solid wins are against Kessler (the only prime opponent he's ever beaten) and Hopkins (Despite the win over Pavlik, past it).

No.

 

Agreed:thumbsup.

 

Jimmy Wilde, Bob Fitzsimmons and Jim Driscoll. Three fighters definitely better than Calzaghe. He maybe edges top ten.