Is Joe Calzaghe current top 3 P4P?

In my eyes...yes.

 

CHJ told me that he was #1 from 2000-2006, I suppose now because of his age he's either 2 or 3 depending on how you rate what Pac has done this year.

 

I have him at #3 at the moment. A convincing win by either Marquez or Vasquez in their third fight would push them ahead though, probably.

 

Yep. I actually want to put him above Pac but I'm Filipino so I can't.

 

No.

Cotto, Pacquiao and Mayweather are def. above him....

 

not for me 4th in my list mayweather pacman cotto then jc

 

yes, easily. undisputed SMW champ. has beaten his two major challengers in the past 18 months, and is a H2H nightmare for anyone between 160-175. anyone who rates cotto above him is ****ing deluded.

 

PBF
Pac
Calzaghe

 

Cotto ran in the last few rounds against Mosley so that lowered his stock as far as I'm concerned; Calzaghe stood toe to toe with Kessler in the last round like a true warrior.

Pacquaio needs to beat JM Marquez in a rematch (if it happens) to be above Calzaghe.

Mayweather must beat Hatton to stay #1 P4P.

Calzaghe would move to #1 if he fights and beats Hopkins, and if Mayweather loses to Hatton and depending on the result of Pacquiao - JM Marquez.

JM Marquez could be #1 if he beats Pacquaio convincingly :deal

My top 10 currently is roughly:

1. Mayweather
2. Calzaghe
3. JM Marquez
4. Pacquiao
5. Juan Diaz
6. Cotto
7. Hatton
8. Daniel Ponce De Leon
9. Winner of Vasquez - Rafael Marquez
10. Loser of Vasquez - Rafael Marquez

 

Thanks for your comment mosley trumps lacy and he trumps kessler thats why IMO he is above jc in my list. Do you doubt cotto could fight 17 donkeys like jc has and won dont get me wrong jc is fourth on the list can not fault the kessler fight.

signed ****ing deluded

 

calzaghe is at #3 above jmm and hopkins. hopkins should even be above jmm.

1. pbf
2. pac
3. calzaghe
4. hopkins
5. jmm

 

Yes.

 

#2.