Is Joe Calzaghe the Greatest British Fighter of All Time?

True.... Audley just missed out.

 

'The British Three Kings' "Skelton,Audley,Williams"

 

No.

He is top 10 though, I'll probably have to review my list some day soon.

 

Very good list, I also consider Fitz to be the finest British fighter of all time :good

 

1 calzaghe
2 lewis
3 buchanan
4 lynch
5 wilde


then its take your pick from conteh,lewis,berg,welsh and turpin

 

:good

Good list.

I'd swap Calzaghe and Buchanan. Not alot in it though. I dont usually have Fitz in mine (is he British or not?!) but if I did he'd be #1 by a long way.

My knowledge on Benny Lynch is limited so I'll take your word for it on that one.

 

5 votes for Calzaghe:nono

"I hereby cast ye five down with the sodomites" (ie: go to the General Forum)

 

Great list; hard to find much fault with this one:good

 

Yes. Because he ALWAYS found a way to win which is almost unheard of at top level. He never slipped up against ponents he should he beaten. He was always able to adapt to the type of opponent. He could punch, he could box, he could guts out a dirty victory,he did everything to win and never lost. No other British boxer comes close

 

You should indulge Trampie on the subject of Wilde then. He seems to truly believe Wilde is the GOAT (not British, but the de facto GOAT!), though he watered this down to placing him 7th (ahead of guys like Ezzard Charles) in his recent attempt at an all-time list.

 

I've never been totally convinced by Lynch being included in a top ten...i'll have to do some research

 

Is he Welsh?

 

20% of respondants think that Cal is Britains #1 ATG....**** me :-(