Is Manny Pacquiao a top 20 Atg

barrera and morales are 122 pounders and never a 118 champion..

 

I will assume that is beating JMM, Cotto and then Mosley or PBF would make him legit top 12. No it wouldn't to get to top 12 you need to get there by beating other ATG's Mayweather and possibly Mosley are the only other ATGs that are present on your list.

Try again.

You still have not answerd my question about Valero and Bradley pushing him passed 3 ATGs on your list.

 

too early to start saying this kind of stuff....fight cotto mosely floyd and then an argument could be made that he makes the grade as far as ATG goes

 

yes, if manny pacquiao KO's any of the four, he is top 8 in my book...at par with pep and better than duran

ofcourse, manny must retire after that, if he losses, his stock goes down

 

:rofl:rofl:rofl:rofl

Koing a 35 year old who he has beaten once and knocked down 4 times jumps him 15 places on your ATG list.

Are you ****ing nuts? :nut

 

beating valero or bradley would make pacquiao an ATG at 140. right now, to many, they do not consider pacquiao as a 140 ATG. one more win over an elite contender would raise his stock.

being the best 140 pounder and fighting great fighters for 2 years would really increase his longetivity factor. and valero and bradley are only decent contenders at 140

 

How on earth is that explaining why it would jump him 3 places on your ATG list?

 

that is assuming JMM beats PBF...manny wont fight JMM if JMM losses to PBF..

 

his longetivity factor at 140:deal and a top 5 140 pounder ever...that is a big accomplishment considering he only has 2 fights

 

pacquiao will never be regarded as a better fighter than duran, end of

 

Even still. 15 places after he KO's a guy who he has beaten before and knocked down 4 times a guy is ludicrous nuthuggery at best

 

Yes are you trying to say that it would jump him 3 places on your ATG list?

That is pathetic.